💥 Zero Bullshit

See no risk, speak no risk

The road to marketing hell is paved with good omissions.

Communications is not always an easy job. Which suits me fine: it keeps me in work! But just like health, tobacco or alcohol, many jobs in finance, savings, banking or property are regulated. And so is the way they communicate.

That creates plenty of headaches. Internationally, it is a huge market distortion. Many registered French crypto firms (PSANs)1 regularly complain about the rules they must follow to hold or sell crypto and to advertise it, while unregulated foreign players come in and do whatever they like. Including marketing to French people, in French, through French influencers, like the Bitget exchange… which sits on the blacklist of the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator2.

But even among regulated players, some take a few liberties with the rules, when they don’t sit on them outright, notably by getting other people to do the talking for them.

Before we start, a few clarifications seem important.

  • This newsletter uses named examples taken from professional communications. It is in no way a settling of scores or a judgement on people, companies, products or services.
  • The facts are presented from a marketing and regulatory angle, according to my own analysis. Except where sanctions have actually been handed down, nothing I write suggests that these practices could be, or will be, punished by a regulator.
  • The people named are named in a professional capacity, and this newsletter must never be used as an excuse to defame or harass them.

The question of whether or not to name people also came up last week, after the newsletter on Ledger. Among the feedback was a co-founder who took the piece badly, for 3 reasons:

  • The cashout figures were supposedly wrong;
  • He was named personally;
  • I had supposedly put a target on his back.

I anonymised several names, but my position has always been to:

  • Not anonymise people who expose themselves voluntarily as part of their business;
  • Not anonymise people who appear in public or easily accessible documents;
  • Anonymise people who are mentioned to illustrate something that is not at the heart of the story;
  • Anonymise sources and witnesses, unless they agree otherwise;
  • Clearly credit public sources, especially journalists and their media.

Every media outlet clearly has its own creed on the subject. But as far as I’m concerned, and I have said it many times, naming someone in connection with a failure is not running that person down. Several times, when I wrote about the collapses of Luko, Masteos, Ynsect and others, I got messages saying that at least they had tried, or that it wasn’t [the CEO’s name]’s fault. Fair enough. I have never blamed anyone by name for a failure, and even if I had, it would not call all of their skills or qualities into question. And yes, it is always easier to analyse a failure after the fact. That doesn’t make the content any less relevant.

With that: happy reading.

Illustration for the newsletter “See no risk, speak no risk”

Note: this issue is a long one, so you can open it in your browser by clicking here.