💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 10

I Am Legend

For a few years now, the long-form podcast has been all the rage. There are of course the ones that really work, like La Martingale, a French personal finance podcast, but above all there is a whole string of 1-, 2- or even 3-hour interviews floating around on YouTube or Spotify, topping out at a few hundred, sometimes a few thousand, views.

To see the scale of these junk podcasts, just type in the names of those guests you see everywhere but nobody actually listens to. One of the best known is obviously Oussama Ammar, whose hosts hope he will come out with a good line or a good story, to get their show talked about. Because that is the whole point: really, the idea is to roll out the red carpet for people in order to nick their audience and exist. And from one show to the next, you find the same clowns, often sorted by the platform they came from, trotting out the same platitudes. Andréa Bensaïd invites Kevin Dufraisse on Little Big Things, who in turn invites Laurine Bemer, who turns up at Thibault Louis’s or on Benoît Dubos’s Scalezia, who hosts Caroline Mignaux, who was just on Andréa Bensaïd’s show, etc. Basically: take the list of Trade Republic and Oh My Poke LinkedIn sponsored posters, and you have half the guests of business podcasts.

Still, like La Martingale, some have chosen to invite different people to tell different stories, and among them is Legend. The show (video and audio) is hosted by Guillaume Pley, a former star of the French music radio station NRJ who also worked at the TV channel M6. Poached to succeed the radio host Cauet, he had in fact already worked for the station, in Belgium, where he had been fired for being erratic. Back then, Pley was a huge star with young people, a direct heir of anything-goes late-night phone-in radio, with everything that can involve in terms of funny, crude or smutty. Midway through the 2018 season, the station abruptly pushed him out. In tears, he announced he was leaving Guillaume Radio after 7 years on air.

The host quickly bounced back on YouTube, notably with the backing of Webedia, where everyone who worked with him describes him as far more relaxed than the stars around him (Squeezie, Norman, Cyprien, etc.). Quite a contrast with his very harsh reputation in radio, where he drove many people to resign from exhaustion6667.

But since Legend, which is a ratings hit, Pley is a different man, according to someone who sees him regularly. Calm, apparently well prepared, the host knows how to put his guests at ease, and above all how to pick them, even if some raise questions. I am thinking of a person whose mental illness seems hard to believe, of an interview with former president Nicolas Sarkozy, whom he served up softballs to just before his trial, or of a flat-earther whose very (very) right-wing leanings Pley forgets to mention, even when he promotes the French far-right group Civitas or QAnon.

In August 2023, Legend hosted Jo Harmendjian, presented as a trader. He is one of the channel’s dozens of guests. Some are famous and come to promote themselves, others, like Jo, just come to tell a story.

When, three months later, the co-founder of RTFKT, Samuel Cardillo, was invited68, things were much less clear. Pley travelled to Dubai, to Samuel’s place, for the interview, which opens with an ad for the cashback site eBuyClub. There is no “commercial collaboration” label on screen, but it is fairly clear from the content. A link in the bio points to RTFKT and shows this:

A simple generic disclaimer? Added later? A sponsor’s request? Or did Cardillo or RTFKT pay?

Where there is no longer any doubt is the first time the Business label appeared on the channel, in January 202469. The guest is Anthony Bourbon70, founder of Feed and TV co-host, who has been promoting a private equity club, Blast, for a while.

The mention under the video for Anthony Bourbon’s 2nd appearance, with a tracked link in Legend’s name that uses “Investissement aux côtés d’Anthony Bourbon” (Investing alongside Anthony Bourbon), which is also the 1st slogan on Blast’s website.

Bourbon trots out his usual spiel, gently bashing the system, and talks at length about Blast. At no point in the video or in the description is there any mention of advertising. And yet this is indeed paid content, viewed more than a million times.

I called out Guillaume Pley on LinkedIn several times, and the “commercial collaboration” label and the generic disclaimer above eventually appeared71. But a far cry from the legal requirements, and above all… the video had already been widely seen.

Same story with Trade Republic’s Matthias Baccino the following month. The commercial collaboration label at the start of the video was again added several days (as was any notion of risk) after the release of this video, whose title is simply incredible:

ANCIEN TRADER ET BANQUIER : COMMENT DEVENIR RICHE EN ÉVITANT LES ARNAQUES [FORMER TRADER AND BANKER: HOW TO GET RICH WHILE AVOIDING SCAMS]

Throughout the video and the whole Trade Republic plug, which runs through the usual spiel, not the slightest notion of risk, and never a word of challenge from Pley, who doesn’t know the subject.

Let’s take a concrete example, which lets Baccino sell his product by running through his anti-inflation pitch.

That 76% of French people don’t understand mortgages, he says. That right now, an average mortgage rate is 4%. But that it is 4% A YEAR.

He is absolutely right about the financial literacy problem, which leads a lot of people to think that a €100K loan at 4% will cost €4,000. And indeed, over 20 years, the cost of your loan comes to 45% of what you borrowed, and in a typical case with the various fees, half of your property.

Baccino is on the verge of tears and says he has a lump in his throat.
Pley says he didn’t know that.
Quite the moment.

Baccino’s moral: if you don’t sell your house for 50% more in 20 years, you’ve lost money. And that is wrong, it is stupid… and above all it goes against Baccino’s own anti-inflation crusade.

Because for 20 years, you will be repaying an old amount with money you earn at the time: so inflation works in your favour. Because it has broadly pushed up wages and prices, and so the price of your house too.

Next, and contrary to what all the numpties who have read too much Kiyosaki (in French) keep yelling, your house is an asset, and borrowing to buy it is not just a liability blowing in the wind: every month, you build up equity in an asset you already have. Coming from someone who advocates scrapping pay-as-you-go state pensions in favour of funded pensions, that is a bit of a shame.

Finally, whatever happens, for 20 years you will have needed somewhere to live. Either you pay rent or you pay a mortgage (roughly). Depending on the case, the region, how long you keep it, etc., one may be better than the other.

This matters, because this show (like all the others mentioned above) keeps playing the same little tune: investing in the stock market is better.

All to promote an ordinary securities account (CTO)72, even though it is clearly not the most advantageous wrapper for a French investor. A message also relayed by many of the brand’s ambassadors, some of them financial advisers, on LinkedIn or YouTube, who often/sometimes forget to explain that they are paid to talk about the broker.73

According to Guillaume Pley himself, the video generated 100,000 Trade Republic account openings.74

When it was shared, Zero Bullshit called out Pley on the lack of legal disclosures, as did Alexandre Lefèvre of Investissements Faciles.

The words “Coopération commerciale” (commercial cooperation) were indeed in the middle of the description, but on release, YouTube’s paid promotion option was not switched on (it is now). On the other hand, none of the short formats (TikTok, Instagram, YouTube Shorts) carries any indication at all, either of advertising or of risk.

And precisely because it is an ad, Guillaume Pley lets Baccino run through his pitch and never comes back on what he says. When he talks, for example, about his 4% account, having repeatedly run down the Livret A, France’s state-regulated tax-free savings account (3%), he forgets to mention that his product is taxed (France’s 30% flat tax) and so pays 2.8%. Less than the Livret A75. Which, to be fair, is justified: the Livret A is capped at €23K. But the omission, left unchallenged, shows just how much this is an ad, and in no way educational or journalistic content.

The other Business episodes carry very uneven disclosures76. In March 2024, the antiques dealer and TV presenter Caroline Margeron came to tell her life story for 1 hour 10 in a Legend Business episode, which is therefore probably, once again, an ad, never declared. The same month, Warner paid Legend to get Christian Clot talking in order to promote Godzilla x Kong, with clear disclosures. They did the same with Marwan Mery, who came to promote Trap.

Likewise when Revolut paid to put Antoine Le Nel in front of 230K people, or when the Order of Malta bought a slot (shared on LinkedIn, where Pley congratulates himself on showcasing good […] through this commercial collaboration77). Or when the trainer Christopher Wangen bought his video.

But when Justin Hutteau came to talk about Respire in May 2024, Pley explains that they are going to talk entrepreneurship and that this is why it is a business format. Not the slightest mention of advertising, once again, either in the video or in the description.

Same story when the highly controversial Clara Gold and her dating app Gigi, whom some compare to a female Oussama Ammar, bought her slot in August: not a single disclosure. The LinkedIn post sharing the video is soberly titled How to earn €12,000 a month?78.

And while in November all the disclosures were fairly clear for the appearance of Alexandre Roubaud of Bitstack, the video leaves you wondering. Sketchily prepared, Pley never spells out the risks even though it is a 1hr 22 plug for Bitcoin. Even if, to be fair, there are no false claims or anything of the “get rich” kind.

And it is the same issue when Blast paid Legend again (and it says so) in January 2025 to bring on Eric Larchevêque, then Rand Hindi79. Between two of Larchevêque’s anecdotes, the point is very much to promote Bitcoin, once again without mentioning risk, or private equity to plug Blast, still without risk. All this a few days after a 2nd interview with Anthony Bourbon was published, with no disclosure at all, either of advertising or of risk. As for Rand Hindi, the comments are scathing, to say the least, but that remains an editorial choice.

While it is conceivable that there were slip-ups, especially at the start, after so many episodes and reminders it cannot be a simple oversight.

Especially since these oversights also show up on TikTok and Instagram. A large share of the content there is still published without any advertising disclosure. Including a clip giving steps to get rich, which is an ad for Blast. No sign of advertising disclosures either when Pley shares on LinkedIn the ad with Larchevêque80, which ended up being taken down quickly81.

Especially since this content is massively chopped up and reposted all over the place in very short formats, without Legend being responsible, of course, since it is an infringement of its intellectual property.

Legend is today clearly a media outlet that uses the audience who came for its (often interesting) editorial content to slip in disguised advertising, and to illegally promote regulated financial products.

And everyone is happy.

Legend, which charged €10,000 for a mention in the first videos, €60,000 after that, then €90,000 for the past few months for Legend Business episodes. The advertisers who, according to two of them, get their money’s worth in conversions. The platforms, for which it generates traffic.

But what about the investors and savers, clearly misled, for whom every protection put in place for them has been knowingly ignored?

We are talking here about the number one French-language podcast82.

Approached for comment, Guillaume Pley did not answer the questions.