But for a long while now, Green Got has been churning out extremely aggressive communication. Last October, I had (in all good faith) mentioned it privately to one of the founders, who told me he would adjust things but that there was nothing nasty about it.
The post61, rather clever and funny in form, talks about inflation eating into purchasing power, with the community manager speaking directly to the reader.
Whereas:
The post got more than 3,000 likes on Instagram and nearly 500 on LinkedIn. One customer was even surprised not to have the same performance. The remark is interesting, not because Green Got would be lying or their product would be bad, but because it shows the problem with communication that is too far removed from reality:
Shortly afterwards, Green Got was communicating heavily about its private equity fundraising via Crowdcube, once again without the slightest mention of risk or liquidity. And since then, their website has carried on communicating without any disclaimer:
The home page of Green Got’s website, using the word “durable” (sustainable), banned by most regulators, but above all the words “rentable et serein” (profitable and serene), then “grandir votre épargne” (grow your savings).
On the second screen, the line quoted in the video has turned into “double profit”, while talking about “performance solide” (solid performance).
A problem partly shared by its direct competitor Helios:
But not at Goodvest, which has managed to get round the constraint by not talking about performance in its opening words:
While adding the appropriate warnings as soon as performance comes up.
More broadly, this risk problem is present at a great many players. While, as I mentioned before, fintechs like Bricks.co have clearly taken the issue in hand by displaying the risks, I pointed out last year that Blast, a private equity club, was not complying with these disclosures.
In its defamation suit against Zero Bullshit62, Blast actually made a point of this. In its formal notice, the company stated:
That, contrary to my statements about an (alleged) absence of risk warnings on the Blast website, the warning appeared in several places: (i) at the bottom of the home page, (ii) at the bottom of the “Le Club” page and (iii) at the bottom of the “Comment ça marche” (How it works) page, as well as in the contractual documents for each deal.
Points repeated in its submissions to the court:
That the claim that no risk warning appears on the main pages of the Blast website, or in the “Home”, “Le Club” and “Comment ça marche” sections, is simply untrue, and easy to check by visiting the site and those sections.
Yet the AMF’s position-recommendation DOC-2023-0563 is clear, and in line with decisions and positions taken on other financial products:
To be fair, it says, information must present the various features of the offer in a balanced way. The platform must in particular refrain from emphasising the potential advantages of the investment without also stating, correctly and very prominently, the associated drawbacks and/or the corresponding risks (…) In this context, it cannot be accepted (…) that the presentation of the risks of the proposed offer or of the detailed offer is only placed at the bottom of a marketing communication while the advantages are in the body of the document (…) Particular attention should be paid to the typography used, notably font size, and to the colours used when communicating on performance, so that this information is not given prominence. By way of illustration, using colour or bold type to present the risks helps make them more visible.
And yet, even today, Blast still talks about favourable conditions and freedom, for investments from €1,000, without mentioning the high risk of capital loss and the illiquidity inherent in private equity.
The first mention of risk comes at the very end of the page, in the footer64. That said, Blast’s argument through its lawyer shows that the claim is indeed true.
You find exactly the same problem at Trade Republic65, which is particularly surprising given that it has just obtained a banking licence, so regulators must have been through it. It talks about the PEA, ETFs and even crypto using words such as easy and safe. Once again, you have to wait for the footer to see a warning about the risk of capital loss or about the tax treatment of the interest-bearing account.
A survey of the platforms shows that risks are:
Probably for fear of scaring the consumer off. Whereas all you need to do is not limit your main message to performance, and you won’t have to splash the risks everywhere.
And yet Green Got and Blast are fintechs with very strong communities. Blast calls itself a club, whose members are indeed very active and genuinely defend the brand (which has a somewhat combative tone, as I found out first-hand). Same at Green Got, whose customers are behind 35% of account openings. In fact, the fintech doesn’t call itself a fintech but “the movement of a generation”. And while the phrase may sound a bit bullshit and marketing, having such engaged communities is a real feat, especially for financial products.
Hiding the downsides or dressing up reality should be seen as a major risk, when your biggest asset under management is your customers’ trust.
That said, it shouldn’t (normally) stop Green Got from getting its banking licence, which it is working on, like Lydia for Sumeria, and which the fintech hopes to obtain next December.
Nor does it call into question the value of these platforms, which bring different ways of investing or managing money. Especially since, yes, honestly, your money will always be better off at Green Got or Helios than at BNP, and its impact will always be more positive.
But above all, we are a long way from those who have institutionalised all this outright.