💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Greener than green

But that doesn’t mean the product is rubbish, or even that the intention is bad.

In December 2024, the YouTuber Amistory, a social media specialist, published an excellent 40-minute investigation into the training-course con artists who sell wealth and freedom54.

The video is sponsored by the fintech Green Got, a French “green” neobank. It is perfectly well flagged, with:

  • YouTube’s built-in “Includes paid promotion” label;
  • The words “Collaboration commerciale” (commercial collaboration) in the top left of the screen when the video talks about Green Got;
  • A promo code on screen, usable via a link in the description (admittedly not flagged as an affiliate link, but it is still fairly clear).

As in every partnership, the creator runs through the brand’s pitch. And Green Got’s is sometimes shaky, even untrue, as I have pointed out several times (here or here). Amistory runs through it, for example, when talking about how banks use deposits for lending:

The problem, she says, is that they are mostly projects that harm the environment.

That is somewhat untrue and at the very least exaggerated. Because while some banks massively back fossil fuels, and it shows in their carbon footprint, nothing allows you to say they “mostly” back problematic projects. But Julie Jouanne, Amistory’s agent who set up the deal, explains why, attaching several serious sources:

Their job as a creator’s agent, she explains, is to make sure that the content broadcast complies with the influencer law […]; they pay attention to the arguments used and rely as much as possible on the material supplied by the brand.

Shortly before, it was the YouTuber Cyrus North plugging Green Got in a video55 (where it is clearly stated that it is an ad). This time it was the famous “€x = x tonnes of CO2 a year”, an argument also used, then dropped, by its competitor Helios, and which is nothing but greenwashing.

This calculation, done by Rift using data from Carbone4 Finance, says roughly that €1,000 = 0.5t of CO2 a year, and that the average deposit is €14K, so 7t of CO256. Except that the same Carbone4, like the Ademe, France’s environment agency, puts the figure at around 10t of CO2 a year per person57, and banking is a minor part of it. So, what gives?

Basically, there isn’t much of an answer as to why one body calculates this figure on one side, and on the other doesn’t include it in other calculations58.

What is interesting, though, is that the status of payment service provider (PSP) agent59 is, in Carbone4’s view, the least ideal answer for the climate, since the money actually ends up in a bank (Arkea for Green Got, Crédit Agricole for Helios).

To put it simply, the calculation takes the carbon footprint of a bank’s investments, divides it by its deposits, and shows how much, relatively, each deposit finances. And so lets you compare the carbon intensity of banks. It is not necessarily accurate, but it is perfectly comparable, and that is what matters.

Where it becomes a lie, a so-called reciprocity fallacy, is in making people believe that if €1,000 = 0.5 t a year in bank X, then if I withdraw my €1,000, I remove 0.5 t. Because banks don’t use all their lending capacity. So if I withdraw my money, I remove part of the bank’s capacity to lend, but that takes nothing out of the atmosphere, and doesn’t necessarily produce less carbon either.

The other problem comes further into Amistory’s video:

That your savings earn money, she tells viewers, with returns of up to 9.44% on their assurance-vie.

To back the claim, a screenshot of the website appears, and it too is thoroughly problematic.

  • The past performance warning is tiny and low-contrast, while the word “grandir” (grow) is underlined and large, and the returns are highlighted in yellow. This is exactly what the AMF has already sanctioned.
  • The Green-Got assurance-vie was launched in March 2024, so talking about 2023 performance makes no sense;
  • The figure is apparently a backtest, whose result changes over time, on one particular profile;
  • And above all, there is no mention whatsoever of the risk of capital loss in the video, though the warning was slipped into the description, which takes a click.

Last August, it was the excellent Simon Puech60 plugging Green Got, entirely legally, in a very cool video on rogue trader Kerviel. This time the plug talks about the assurance-vie and the account, without a single problematic claim, and without mentioning returns. While still getting a clear message across.

Which goes to show: it can be done!
And it has just as much impact.