That is exactly why Trade Republic’s 2022 campaign should give us pause.
Because it uses people with effective (and possibly true) storytelling to get the brand’s sales pitch across, without explaining that the message is remote-controlled, and without stating the risks, which are very real.
If I am going on at length here (and I’m not done) about Trade Republic, it is because the brand has been the most visible for 2 years. Probably because it has the most money, but also because it is the most innovative in its communication, which, it must be said, is effective and very skilful marketing. All to promote a product which, it must also be said, is rather interesting.
But the German broker is obviously not the only one to forget to mention risks in influencer campaigns.
Several times (here or here) I have talked about the problem with community fundraising rounds, where companies raise equity from their own customers and fans. Because the product is much harder to understand than a share, the risks much higher, and yet the rules are far looser.
In April 2023, the small poke bowl chain Oh My Poke was looking to raise €1.4M to grow its restaurant network. The crowdfunding platform SoWeFund accepted the deal, for €600K. A landing page42 praises the investment without ever mentioning the risks, apart from a drop-down box on the second-to-last line of the page. It was itself shared in a LinkedIn post by SoWeFund, without the slightest mention of risk43, announcing that 500 people had invested more than €260K. In an interview, one of the co-founders, Julien Boissin, owns up to using influencers, a subject he says he knows well, even if it costs a bit of money44. Boissin knows the subject so well that, in another podcast, he states45:
That influencers are very tightly regulated, there’s the DGCCRF and all that, you can’t do just anything, especially for a crowdfunding round, because it is people’s money after all.
The round was indeed pushed by several LinkedIn influencers who were all paid, though none of them said so. Nor did they give any information about the risks (capital loss and illiquidity, in particular). After a few remarks, some added the ad disclosure after the fact, but at the end of the post, like Raibed Tahri46, Sixtine Moullé-Berteaux47, Chris Scholly48, Hugo Bentz49 or Ruben Taieb50. I touched on it briefly at the time.
When the first influencer posted, he remembers, it was lead after lead after lead, it was incredible.
Despite 4M views51, the counter never went any higher, and the target was never reached. Yet the podcast announces that the brand raised €3M thanks to LinkedIn influencers52, a claim confirmed by Julien Boissin. At no point does he explain that the round never happened.
In reality the company was already in very bad shape, and it was declared insolvent on 31 May 2023, barely a month after the round opened, and 2 months before his podcast53. On 30 January 2024, the holding company that was meant to raise the money was put into compulsory liquidation. Of the 11 subsidiaries running the restaurants, 8 were liquidated in 2024 and 1 no longer has any premises. Apparently only one restaurant is left, on rue de Washington in Paris.
Since then, the experience has completely vanished from Julien Boissin’s CV, and he has refocused his profile on… LinkedIn coaching.
At least nobody lost any money. Which is not the case for some community rounds, like that of Masteos, whose story I told at length (in French).