💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 11

Round and round the garden

But obviously, Legend is not the only one. For several years, M6 has established itself as the springboard for fintechs.

In January 2022, Bricks appeared on Capital83. This business magazine show regularly showcases products or solutions. When it featured Prello last year, for its gradual home-buying service, you could argue it was a grey area, because it is a kind of loan, and not really an investment. But here, Bricks is clearly presented as an alternative that lets you invest in property from €10. Which is factually wrong: Bricks issues royalties and you are basically investing in Bricks, roughly as you would in a property company, but in no way in property itself. Which mattered when performance deteriorated sharply, to the point that the AMF stepped in.

The fact remains that M6 never once highlighted the risks. And that Bricks was swamped with sign-ups, to the point that the site went down for a while.

It is also on M6 that the TV show Qui veut être mon associé ?, France’s version of Dragons’ Den, regularly airs, where investors announce in a few minutes that they are putting large sums into companies. As if being a VC were a few-minute oral exam. In the newsletter on Blast, I explained at length that many of these deals never happen, and several testimonies have been popping up on LinkedIn in recent weeks. Not because of lying, but precisely because a deal is not done in a few minutes on TV. And yet it is clearly the show’s success that made possible the launch, also successful, of the Blast Club.

On 6 January 2025, the channel sent out a press release about the deal between M6 Publicité and Trade Republic84. For 2 months, the channel would air Capital Épargne (Capital Savings), riding on the Capital brand, Monday to Friday at 8.20pm, presented by Julien Courbet. For Baccino, the aim is to let everyone take control of their financial future by tackling the misconceptions about money that too often stop people from achieving long-term financial stability.

The 1st episode is an all-out attack on the system:

  • On pay-as-you-go state pensions (not enough contributors compared with beneficiaries any more)
  • Inflation is eating into your savings (with a giant shortcut: your purchasing power is falling, and with the same amount you can buy fewer things)
  • Then it scares you with likely tax rises to come
  • Before finishing on public debt having tripled.

Oh dear. But don’t panic, says the video, everyone can get started at their own pace. Phew. Then comes Courbet’s mug, and Trade Republic is never clearly named as the solution. But honestly, it is not far off disinformation.

I couldn’t find any trace of the programme or of it being aired on M685, but the episodes are indeed on Trade Republic’s YouTube channel. You will find86:

  • The episode mentioned above
  • Is inflation eating your savings?, whose conclusion is that you should invest your money to avoid losing purchasing power.
  • Fees: stop throwing your money out of the window, where Courbet urges you to ask your banker about fees (if you have 5 more minutes, ask Trade Republic how it makes money through PFOF87, a highly controversial practice88).
  • Having your cake and eating it with the 50/30/20 budget?
  • Look after the pennies: learn to optimise your spending!, which is about making money through cashback (which one of Trade Republic’s offers provides).
  • The power of compound interest: is time money?
  • Saving, investing or trading: learn the difference!, which sets out to explain that saving earns you nothing, that trading inevitably loses you money, and that you should invest, which is precisely the word Trade Republic uses.
  • Handle the unexpected with a rainy-day fund!, where, surprisingly, there is no mention of interest-bearing accounts, like the one Trade Republic has just launched.
  • Saving and investing on a small salary? It’s possible!
  • Your money deserves a plan: better safe than sorry!

These first ten episodes are not shamefully wrong. But amid basic, sensible tips (spreading your money, a safety cushion, etc.), the messages are clearly steered in Trade Republic’s direction.

Obviously: that is what advertising is.

That said, it shows why the subject of financial education is problematic and biased. Other players could perfectly well say it is better to invest in private equity, to finance the real economy. Or fill up your Livret A, out of national pride. Or go for crypto, to limit your exposure to the banking system. Or move to a green neobank, to stop financing oil. Or try to get a pay rise, to have a better pension. Or go self-employed and invest for your own retirement. Or, conversely, stuff yourself with a Madelin contract, a French pension plan for the self-employed.

If financial education doesn’t exist, it is because those who promote it want to do so in their own interest.

If we were objective, we would explain to people why the Livret A always pays less than inflation. Precisely because it is guaranteed. Because the guaranteed rate is indexed to central bank rates. But explaining that also makes you understand that the guaranteed rate moves. And that a product paying 4% when the guaranteed rate is 1% is completely different from the same product paying 4% when the guaranteed rate is 3.5%. And therefore that everyone who bashed the Livret A for years, SCPI managers first among them, lied and took savers for idiots.

In the same way that Trade Republic explains why banks take customers for idiots by paying nothing on current accounts, even though they themselves earn interest from the ECB on their own deposits.

The broker is right.
Bankers indeed don’t really want that to get out.
It is clearly storytelling.
Savers come out of it, on balance, as winners.

Approached for comment, Matthias Baccino did not reply.