And this is the heart of the difficulty: the core business of commercial companies is to sell in order to make money. Whether their mission is good or bad, positive or negative, is a value judgement that is hard to make objective.
Personally, I think the online broker Bourse Direct made investing in listed shares cheaper. That the online bank Boursorama democratised it all and made it simpler. And that Trade Republic brought a new experience that is even more accessible and playful. My view: on balance, that’s a good thing.
Likewise, I believe neobanks (Revolut, N26, etc.) finished what traditional institutions had failed to complete with their own online banks. And that green PSP agents (Green Got, Helios) offer an interesting alternative, letting you partly step out of the system. Just as other players (Goodvest, for example) let you invest in more positive assets.
But can you lie (or at least embellish) for a good cause?
I don’t think so, for two reasons.
1️⃣ The less aware a client is of the problems with what they are buying, the more of a pain they will be when something goes wrong. If SCPI investors have been screaming for 2 years, even though the average holder is over 50 and many follow it from a great distance, it is because they were plainly lied to. From bank branch networks to wealth advisers, they were sold SCPIs and office property as something safe with a bright future. And today, these distributors, managers and regulators just say “well, actually, the risks were on page 63 of the KID you signed”.
2️⃣ And more generally, not being squeaky clean with your comms, especially when you do it for a good reason, exposes you to a violent backlash. Nobody expects anything from the sustainability commitments of an average small business that doesn’t communicate. But many people watch the results of Green Got, Time For The Planet or Lita to make sure they match their commitments. And that ultimately forces them to be even cleaner than the others, just because more people are watching. Supporters and detractors alike.
This creates a real distortion of competition, between those who want to do things right, who apply the rules and therefore reduce their marketing effectiveness, and those who play it Wild West.
But here again, it is a bad bet in the long run.
While Corum or Sogénial were sanctioned for their marketing practices, and others may be one day, these managers cannot be held responsible for any losses, should they come. That is in fact the answer given to savers complaining about losses at Primonial, Amundi or other dodgy SCPIs: the rules were followed.
Quite so. These managers and their distributors handed out pretty brochures, approved by compliance officers and their 30 compliance managers, had clients sign pretty KYC forms, handed out KIDs, KIIDs, disclosure documents and other delights of the PRIIPs regulation, plus quarterly reports, annual reports, subscription forms, information notes, articles of association, and much more besides, some of it even less fun.
That is why today everyone is protected: manager, distributor, regulator. But not the client.
Conversely, today’s cowboys could well pay for it tomorrow. I wish no crash on any of the players mentioned, nor on the many less high-profile competitors they have and that I have not mentioned. But if things go wrong, they could be held directly responsible by the regulators.
In the end, it feels as if we are caught between two eras.
I won’t insult you by concluding with a golden mean fallacy that would give the illusion that neutrality is possible. It doesn’t exist.
But the question we should perhaps be asking is: who is in a position to say what is good for French investors?
If I don’t have the answers, I will at least have tried to pin down the problem.
Approached for comment, the AMF said it did not wish to answer the questions.
Neither the ACPR, the DGCCRF nor the ARPP responded to requests for comment.
My name is Benjamin Charles, and I provide branding, positioning and content creation consulting for companies in finance, property and web3.
👉 Get in touch, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es
👉 Send me a brief for a business project
👉 Book a video call to present a project or a service (€300 per call)