💥 Zero Bullshit

1 Prestataires de services sur actifs numériques: digital asset service providers, the French registration status for crypto firms

2 “Listes noires des sociétés et sites non autorisés : Forex, options binaires, biens divers, produits dérivés sur crypto-actifs, usurpations...” [Blacklists of unauthorised companies and websites: forex, binary options, miscellaneous goods, crypto-asset derivatives, impersonation...], AMF

3 Direction générale de la Concurrence, de la Consommation et de la Répression des fraudes: the French government’s directorate for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control

4 “Un influenceur, créateur d'un projet NFT promettant divers gains inexistants et un enrichissement rapide, notamment via un jeu (Play-to-earn) qui n'a jamais vu le jour, sanctionné pour pratiques commerciales trompeuses” [An influencer behind an NFT project promising various non-existent gains and quick riches, notably through a play-to-earn game that never saw the light of day, penalised for misleading commercial practices]

5 “« J’accepte mon erreur »: le youtubeur TheKairi78 épinglé par la répression des fraudes pour une vente douteuse de NFT” [‘I accept my mistake’: YouTuber TheKairi78 penalised by the fraud authorities over a dubious NFT sale], Raphael Grably, BFM TV, 12 December 2024

6 In reality, it also involved promoting a fraudulent platform, even though the story did not mention it directly.

7 “Bitcoin : l’influenceuse Nabilla a payé 20.000 euros d’amende” [Bitcoin: influencer Nabilla paid a €20,000 fine], Sandra Mathorel, Les Echos investir, 28 July 2021

8 “Qui est Julien Bert, cet influenceur sulfureux épinglé par la Répression des fraudes ?” [Who is Julien Bert, the controversial influencer penalised by the fraud authorities?], Klara Durand and Margot Ruault, Le Figaro, 21 July 2023

9 “Quand les arnaques aux produits financiers en ligne ciblent les jeunes” [When online financial product scams target young people], Capucine Cousin, L’Agefi, 7 July 2022

10 This newsletter is used as an example because it is high-profile and regularly cited in the media.
Caroline Jurado is not the only influencer to have talked about Bitget or promoted Oval3, but she is the one who has come up most often in articles.

11 “Décision de la Commission des sanctions du 29 avril 2021 à l'égard de la société Corum Asset Management” [Enforcement Committee decision of 29 April 2021 regarding Corum Asset Management], SAN-2021-07, AMF

12 Anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (LCB-FT in French)

13 “Décision de la Commission des sanctions du 2 juillet 2021 à l'égard de la société Perial Asset Management, SAN-2021-12” [Enforcement Committee decision of 2 July 2021 regarding Perial Asset Management, SAN-2021-12], AMF

14 “Décision de la Commission des sanctions du 12 septembre 2024 à l'égard de la société Sogenial Immobilier et de M. Jean-Marie Souclier” [Enforcement Committee decision of 12 September 2024 regarding Sogenial Immobilier and Mr Jean-Marie Souclier], SAN-2024-09, AMF

15 Distribution rate on market value (taux de distribution sur valeur de marché)

16 Internal rate of return

17 Without there necessarily being a direct link between my first post on the subject and the AMF stepping in a few days later.

18 Indicateurs de performance [Performance indicators], Bricks

19 Conflict of interest note: I had several job interviews with Matthias Baccino for Trade Republic in summer 2021 which (I believe) ended in a rejection. These meetings have no influence whatsoever on my opinion or my analysis.

20 Post by Caroline Mignaux

21 Post by Sylvain Tillon

22 “L’influence marketing débarque sur LinkedIn pour le meilleur… ou le pire ?” [Influencer marketing lands on LinkedIn, for better… or for worse?], Minted, 21 September 2022

23 Post by Matthias Baccino

24 “Ce que tout le monde devrait savoir sur l'argent et l’investissement (avec Matthias Baccino)” [What everyone should know about money and investing (with Matthias Baccino)], Matthieu Louvet, S’investir, YouTube, 20 November 2024

25 “Cartographie 2024 des marchés et des risques” [2024 markets and risks outlook], pages 8, 114, 130, 137, AMF, 28 June 2024

26 Unlike Robinhood, Trade Republic does not offer copy trading.

27 No Limits? Effects of FOMO and Gamification on Individual Investment Behaviour in Neo-broker Stock Trading, Bomnüter, Udo; Kleinselbeck, Brigitte; Reusch, Heiko; Schmidt, Hendrik, SSOAR, 2023

28 Hype or New Normal? Insights into the motives and behavior of a new generation of investors, Kritikos, Handrich, Gorgels, Priem, Morales, Diw Econ, 2022

29 Neo-brokers in the EU: Developments, benefits and risks, ESMA TRV Risk Analysis Orderly Markets, ESMA, 9 July 2024

30 Among 250,000 users, 34,000 of whom were excluded to keep the sample representative.

31 The effects of trading apps on investment behavior over time, Jonas Freibauer,Silja Grawert, Marc Oliver Rieger, The European Journal of Finance, 19 August 2024
Fun & Games : investment gamification and implications for capital markets, CFA Institute, 2022
Gaming trading: how trading apps could be engaging consumers for the worse, Lucy Hayes, Stephen O’Neill, Max Spohn, Cherryl Ng https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/research-articles/gaming-trading-how-trading-apps-could-be-engaging-consumers-worse

32 “Loi pour la confiance dans l'économie numérique” [Law on confidence in the digital economy], 21 June 2004

33 “Loi n° 2023-451 du 9 juin 2023 visant à encadrer l'influence commerciale et à lutter contre les dérives des influenceurs sur les réseaux sociaux” [Law no. 2023-451 of 9 June 2023 to regulate commercial influence and combat abuses by influencers on social media]

34 Autorité de Régulation Professionnelle de la Publicité: the French advertising industry’s self-regulatory body

35 “L’AMF et l’ARPP lancent le certificat de l’influence responsable dans la finance” [The AMF and the ARPP launch the responsible influence certificate for finance], 7 September 2023

36 Direction générale de la Concurrence, de la Consommation et de la Répression des fraudes: the French government’s directorate for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control

37 “Affaire Booba-Magali Berdah : on vous résume la guerre entre le rappeur et l’agente d’influenceurs” [The Booba-Magali Berdah affair: a summary of the war between the rapper and the influencer agent], Lucas Rojouan, Ouest France, 3 October 2023

38 “Dérives des influenceurs : la DGCCRF épingle la moitié des stars contrôlées, certaines pourraient être poursuivies” [Influencer abuses: the DGCCRF flags half the stars it inspected, some could be prosecuted], Paméla Rougerie, Le Parisien, 3 April 2024

39 “Publication des sanctions et injonctions : un outil très efficace pour informer les consommateurs et dissuader les professionnels indélicats” [Publishing sanctions and injunctions: a very effective tool to inform consumers and deter unscrupulous businesses], DGCCRF, 2 June 2023

40 “Guide de bonne conduite des Influenceurs” [Influencers’ code of good conduct], Ministère de l’économie et des finances, 1 June 2023
“Accompagner les influenceurs, protéger les consommateurs” [Supporting influencers, protecting consumers], Ministère de l’économie et des finances, 1 June 2023

41 “Baromètre AMF de l'épargne et de l’investissement - 2023” [AMF savings and investment barometer, 2023], December 2023, AMF
“Baromètre AMF de l'épargne et de l’investissement - 2024” [AMF savings and investment barometer, 2024], January 2025, AMF

42 SoWeFund website

43 SoWeFund post

44 Interview on Investisseur.TV, 2023

45 “Comment lever grâce aux influenceurs LinkedIn ?” [How to raise money thanks to LinkedIn influencers?], Conseil de Growth, 1 July 2023

46 Post by Raibed Tahri

47 Post by Sixtine Moullé-Berteaux

48 Post by Chris Scholly
Comment made before the edit:

49 Post by Hugo Bentz
Comment made before the edit:

50 Post by Ruben Taieb

51 According to Caroline Rousset

52 LinkedIn post by Alexis Bouvet

53 The podcast was published on 1 July 2023 and it does not say when it was recorded.

54 “« Deviens MILLIONNAIRE » : J’ai enquêté sur ces Influenceurs qui te manipulent” [‘Become a MILLIONAIRE’: I investigated the influencers who manipulate you], Amistory, December 2024

55 “Peut-on restreindre ses désirs pour la planète ?” [Can we curb our desires for the planet?], Cyrus North, 9 April 2023

56 “Faire sa part avec son argent, partie 1 : le compte courant” [Doing your bit with your money, part 1: the current account], Carbone 4, 13 February 2024

57 “MyCO2 présente un nouveau calcul de l’empreinte carbone personnelle” [MyCO2 presents a new calculation of the personal carbon footprint], Carbone4, 11 January 2022

58 Several people I asked gave different versions, which in any case did not affect the argument.

59 Payment service provider
This is the current status of Helios and Green Got (and also Qonto)

60 “Le mensonge le plus cher de l’histoire” [The most expensive lie in history], Simon Puech, 13 August 2024

61 Green Got LinkedIn post, October 2024

62 Blast sued Zero Bullshit twice in 2024 for defamation and breach of business law. Blast was ordered to pay costs in both cases.

63 “Communications publicitaires des prestataires de services de financement participatif” [Marketing communications of crowdfunding service providers], 16 June 2023, AMF

64 Blast.club home page

65 Trade Republic home page

66 “De NRJ à Legend : Guillaume Pley, le buzz ou rien” [From NRJ to Legend: Guillaume Pley, buzz or bust], Romane Lizée, Streetpresse, 10 October 2024

67 “« Erreur de communication », « 0 sur 20 en gestion de bad buzz »: Guillaume Pley, ancien de NRJ, réagit aux accusations dont il fait l’objet, sa réponse ne fait pas l’unanimité” [‘Communication error’, ‘0 out of 20 for handling bad buzz’: former NRJ host Guillaume Pley responds to the accusations against him, and his answer divides opinion], Xavier Verheyden, Ciné Télé Revu, 13 April 2023

68 “IL CRÉE SA BOITE À 9 ANS, DEVIENT MILLIONNAIRE ET POSSÈDE 9 SATELLITES (Samuel Cardillo)” [HE STARTED HIS COMPANY AT 9, BECAME A MILLIONAIRE AND OWNS 9 SATELLITES (Samuel Cardillo)], Legend, 29 November 2023

69 “ENTREPRENEUR : IL GAGNE 100 MILLIONS D'EUROS GRÂCE À SON IDÉE D'ENTREPRISE ! (‪@anthonybourbon1‬)” [ENTREPRENEUR: HE MAKES 100 MILLION EUROS THANKS TO HIS BUSINESS IDEA! (@anthonybourbon1)], Legend, 24 January 2024

70 Conflict of interest note: following the July 2024 newsletter on Blast (in French), Anthony Bourbon made a number of repeated remarks about me, which have been the subject of a complaint for defamation and another for harassment. These matters have not been ruled on.
A few days after publication, the company Blast took me to court twice in urgent proceedings, for defamation and breach of trade secrets. The company Blast was ordered to pay costs in both cases, notably €5,000 in legal fees.
None of this plays any part in the analysis of content featuring Anthony Bourbon, Blast or people who may be associated with them.

71 Without there necessarily being a direct link between my intervention and the label appearing.

72 Since January 2025, Trade Republic has also offered a PEA

73 Post by Charles-Elias Farah
Post by Nicolas Cheron where the “Publicité” (advertisement) label clearly appears

74 LinkedIn post by Guillaume Pley

75 At the time of broadcast

76 “LA VIE INCROYABLE DE CE FRANÇAIS QUI TRAVAILLE POUR PLAYSTATION AU JAPON (succès, séisme…)” [THE INCREDIBLE LIFE OF THIS FRENCHMAN WHO WORKS FOR PLAYSTATION IN JAPAN (success, earthquake…)], Legend, 15 November 2024
“RACEM PDG DE LEGALPLACE: CRÉER SA BOÎTE FACILEMENT, FAIRE 1M€ AVEC 4000€, LES SECRETS D'APPLE & IKEA” [RACEM, CEO OF LEGALPLACE: STARTING A COMPANY EASILY, MAKING €1M WITH €4,000, THE SECRETS OF APPLE & IKEA], Legend, 11 October 2024

77 Post by Guillaume Pley

78 Post by Guillaume Pley

79 “« LES PREMIERS HUMAINS IMMORTELS SONT DÉJÀ NÉS » CRYOGÉNISATION, CLONAGE HUMAIN ET IMMORTALITÉ” [‘THE FIRST IMMORTAL HUMANS HAVE ALREADY BEEN BORN’: CRYONICS, HUMAN CLONING AND IMMORTALITY], Legend, 17 January 2025

80 Post by Guillaume Pley, 22 January 2025

81 The post was deleted shortly after my remark about the missing ad disclosure, but no link can be established, especially as 2 days later came the news of the violent kidnapping of David Balland, co-founder of Ledger, not far from Eric Larchevêque’s home, for financial reasons. The YouTube interview, published a week earlier, is still online.

82 In Pley’s own terms and stats

83 Bricks Facebook page

84 M6 press release
Trade Republic press release

85 Which obviously does not mean it was not aired.

86 At the time of writing this section. Others have surely been published since.

87 Payment for order flow: a fee paid by a market maker to a broker for routing its clients’ orders to it, often in exchange for better execution prices.

88 The controversy surrounding payment for order flow (PFOF), where are we heading?, Finnius, 23 November 2022