💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Numbers games

The indicator problem raised above is a constant. For SCPIs, it is the ASPIM, the trade body of French property fund managers, that keeps everyone more or less in line, and the calculation was in fact changed a few years ago. For crowdfunding, on the other hand, and I have talked about it often, it is a total shambles. Everyone communicates with their own figures, with very different definitions, without the slightest control, and every year the vague, toothless association that groups a few players together puts out a pointless study with EY. We learn that the average return is X%. Which nobody cares about, since we are talking about bonds, and what matters is not the rate clients sign up for, but what they actually get, once delays and defaults are taken into account.

Several investors have even set up their own sites to shed light for others, such as Alexandre Lefèvre of Investissements Faciles or Patrick Setzekorn of Argent & Salaire. In return for their work, they use affiliate links (clearly flagged as advertising) pointing to these platforms. Enough to generate between €8K and €25K a month in revenue, depending on the month and the blog (since there are others).

It was this battle of numbers that made me want to write regularly on LinkedIn a few years ago, when I started analysing Bricks, which was communicating figures very different from its results, while often forgetting to talk about its risks. That exchange of fire earned me behaviour that bordered on harassment at the time but, by the admission of Cédric O’Neill, the boss of Bricks, himself, it made the platform change:

  • Bricks borrowed the idea of my tracking table to give its investors clarity;
  • The AMF stepped in during the fundraising to cap it at €8M17;
  • Bricks reworked part of its communication, notably on risks.

When the AMF asked Bricks to switch from a royalties model to bonds, the proptech became a fintech (in French) that slowly fell back into line. You can still find some projects better than others, but it has to be said that the current problems are almost exclusively with the royalties projects. And the platform is open about its statistics18.

On the other side of crowdfunding sits fractional property, where the platforms fallen in battle could fill a war memorial. And on this side of the fight, the figures are pure hell, since everyone has their own definition of yield. In fact, getting a standard in place was one of Zero Bullshit’s goals before the summer. Those discussions led to a meeting between players that we were then supposed to coordinate, but the project had to be dropped after intense harassment this summer, triggered by a player targeted by one of the newsletters.

The fact remains that today, when a fractional platform announces x%, nobody knows where the fees are, what is included, whether there is a waiting period before income starts, whether there is a scenario where the shares are revalued, and even less how it was valued.

But the issue of how risks, performance and influencers are communicated is much wider too.