In February 2022, Trade Republic19 was one of the first brands to embrace influencer marketing on LinkedIn. Long a big line in consumer brands’ marketing budgets on YouTube or Instagram, it was still very marginal on LinkedIn.
At the end of 2021, the German broker hired Leenq, an influencer agency set up by Hugues Trijasse, a serial entrepreneur behind the new-media brand French Startuper (social media only) and several newsletters, and above all a big name on LinkedIn at the time (a little quieter now). Shortly after this campaign, the agency (which still exists) was bought by Coudac, a marketing agency founded by another LinkedIn figure, Théo Lion.
The main aim of the campaign was to get the brand talked about, more than to drive downloads (even though there was a promotion offering €200 of free shares for a €5 deposit), and three angles were offered to around thirty content creators:
Straight after, as is usually the case, the creators received a brief with the brand’s talking points. Each would get between €500 and €1,500 for their post.
Some were freelancers selling services (Caroline Mignaux20, Caroline Jurado), startup bosses (Grégoire Gambatto, Harold Gardas, Andréa Bensaïd, Antoine Perigne) and others very visible on the platform (Sylvain Tillon21, Ulysse Lubin, Jean Pascal Mollet, Ruben Taieb). And in any case all in the top 100 most followed and read profiles on LinkedIn.
In early January, 23 posts landed on LinkedIn on the same day, which stirred up the regular readers a bit. Hugues Trijasse was jubilant22:
In his words, the biggest influencer marketing operation ever seen on LinkedIn in France.
That is probably still true today. As for me, that is precisely when I started writing… this newsletter. Or at least taking notes. Because I was stunned to see so many people with such big audiences urging others to invest:
When the posts went out, 6 out of 23 said (all at the end of the post) that it was an ad, and only 1 mentioned risk.
Several followers, including savings professionals (and me), were dismayed by such carelessness, among them Grégory Guilmin:
Now paid by Trade Republic, he is one of its most active ambassadors on LinkedIn.
Still, faced with the number of negative comments, several influencers panicked and some deleted their post. Hugues Trijasse messaged each creator asking them to add a disclaimer written by the brand, explaining that it was the AMF that had leaned on Trade Republic:
PS: Investing in the stock market involves a risk of capital loss. The value of investments can go down as well as up and may result in losses greater than the amount initially invested. Individual investors should make their own decisions or seek advice from authorised professionals, and above all educate themselves.
PS2: This post is sponsored.
The two biggest posts, by Andréa Bensaïd and Grégoire Gambetto, each got 120K views. All for a budget of around €50K according to my information, €100K according to Minted’s.
In a post on his personal account, the platform’s very media-savvy boss, Matthias Baccino (who picked up around 3,000 followers during the campaign), defends the operation23. Aware that some people felt spammed, he opens by ironically claiming that this is not a post sponsored by Trade Republic, then explains that the aim was to inform and educate French people about good investment habits.
But like many product sellers, such as Blast’s Anthony Bourbon, Baccino uses an almost social discourse, championing financial education and protecting everyone through their money24. Across his interviews, this close associate of French politician Xavier Bertrand leverages his experience as a trader (although I believe he was more on the sales side) and lays out a real financial vision in which everyone should take their destiny into their own hands. Regularly, and probably rightly, he lays into consumer credit, explaining how much damage it does to most people’s finances. A point regulators regularly make too. But he forgets that, among the risks that now come up every year in the AMF’s risk map25, there is the gamification of investing, which is one of the very foundations of the strategy26 of Robinhood or Trade Republic27.
An issue troubling enough for Trade Republic to pay researchers to show the opposite, in a paper that was never peer-reviewed28. The paper was regularly cited in the press, apparently fed by the broker’s PR people, and used by lobbyists with ESMA, the EU markets regulator29. And yet, rather than research, the paper comes from a survey carried out by… Trade Republic among its own customers30. Unlike other research on the subject31, addiction never comes up.
In the humanist vision of society he holds, says Matthias Baccino, the role of those who know is to help those who don’t […] and not to profit from that difference.
That is not necessarily wrong.
Just as the lack of financial education is real.
But we will see how problematic it is to make people believe that these solutions are some kind of common good delivered by private companies.