In reality, there are two different issues with this campaign: and that is the whole problem.
Because on the one hand, it is an advertising operation. Since 2004 and the LCEN, France’s digital economy law32, anyone paid to say something on the internet has been obliged to disclose it. It is true that the so-called Delaporte-Vojetta law on influencers33, published almost 19 years to the day later, clarified the matter after some high-profile abuses, but it is wrong to claim, as many creators did, that these practices were not regulated.
As early as 2004, article 20 of the law, still in force, provides that:
Any advertising, in whatever form, accessible through an online public communication service must be clearly identifiable as such, and must make clearly identifiable the person or company on whose behalf it is made.
Better still, it clearly states that soliciting for financial investments is prohibited.
The ARPP, France’s advertising self-regulatory body34, has clarified the issue many times in guides, going as far as offering a responsible influence certificate (which nobody cares about)35. The fact remains that the rules, which come from the law, are clear, and are shared by the DGCCRF36 too.
But we are talking about financial investments here, which are overseen by other regulators, notably the AMF and the ACPR, France’s banking and insurance supervisor, depending on the subject.
Here again, while the laws, positions and other doctrines governing the promotion of financial products are not always very clear, nor always well suited to social media, the spirit of the law is fairly clear:
The aim being that investors understand what they are getting into.
Obviously, it isn’t easy. And I say so all the more readily because, on top of my job as newsletter scribbler and part-time righter of wrongs, I help companies in savings (among others) with their communication and marketing. So my job is to make them sell, and to show the product in its best light. Not to say “yeah it’s great but you could lose all your dosh. And die.”
So yes, I can confirm these laws are not always well suited.
But you can respect their spirit.
When I was employed by a fund manager, I set up a pyramid of obligations and a way of presenting them: because if you have to display the risks AND your licence number, those pieces of information don’t actually carry the same weight for the client. By compiling the risks, finding ways to express them in very different contexts (and sizes), and ranking the obligations, it became possible to communicate on very different media, including social media with its specific constraints, in ways that did not meet 100% of the obligations, but that let investors grasp the essentials.
A practice that was not only understood and accepted by several regulators during workshops, but that never led to a single sanction at the inspected companies where it was used.
But this double regulation has caused problems for years, because each body claims it has no jurisdiction and prefers to pass the buck to its neighbour. And despite the AMF’s many clumsy, pointless and barely audible campaigns on influencer financial scams, the very rare sanctions have come from the DGCCRF, which I mentioned above.
Because ever since rapper Booba’s war on the “influscammers”37, which led to the famous Delaporte-Vojetta law, the DGCCRF has publicly named nearly 20 influencers with dubious practices, forcing them to publish their penalty on their social media38, a practice the body now openly embraces39.