In April 2021, the asset manager Corum was fined €600K by the AMF’s enforcement committee11. Anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing (AML/CFT)12 was part of it, and several compliance professionals think that without those failings the sanction might not have been handed down, but the decision is mostly about marketing.
The AMF describes the ads it examined as unclear, inaccurate or misleading,
leading clients to buy products that did not match their risk profiles. The regulator considers the failings very serious, as is the quality of the funds’ sales documentation.
While noting that Corum did not directly profit from these practices and that, to date, no harmed investor had been identified.
The complaints are numerous and interesting, because they show how closely the AMF looks at marketing:
Which could be summed up by this passage from the decision:
The decision notes that the emails about dividends paid by Corum’s SCPIs (French non-listed property funds) carried a warning about various risks, at the top of the emails and in black type. That warning, however, was pushed into the background by the bold, coloured type used for the line about dividend payments. That line, announcing that Corum XL income would now be paid every month, suggested that those dividends were guaranteed.
Over the same inspection period, the AMF found the same kind of problem at Perial, and fined the manager €250K13. The regulator notably blames Perial for not putting in place any process to check its sales literature, citing a YouTube video that did not highlight the risks enough compared with the advantages of the investment it promoted. Finally, the decision states:
That some of the company’s posts on Twitter highlighted the SCPI’s yield and other figures without clearly showing the risks of investing in this type of product, or the fact that this income was no longer guaranteed. The warning on past performance was also left out.
More recently, in September 2024, it was Sogenial’s turn (great name) to be sanctioned, partly on similar grounds14. Once again, the AMF found documents giving an unbalanced picture of the advantages and risks of SCPIs, and others with claims that did not specify that the advertised yield was not guaranteed. The regulator also blames Sogenial for citing its distribution rate on market value (DVM)15 in a few dozen documents without clearly explaining how it was calculated, and for never presenting the IRR16. Basically: they fiddled the numbers to look better.
In fact, you only need to bring up AMF inspections with any fund manager or distributor to see it. The boss of a large firm of wealth advisers explains it to me:
When the AMF turns up, he says, you know they have come to find something. It takes an incredible amount of time, you have to open everything up, hand everything over. And inevitably, across every product and every client, despite the processes you put in place, a document sometimes goes missing because it was not uploaded or filed properly.
Still, these sanctions remain rare and limited to respectable players. Because even if Corum bent the law and the spirit of the law and made a mess of a few bus-back ads, they never openly lied or splashed crazy claims telling investors they would get rich. Even if, once again, these sanctions were handed down alongside other failings.
And the rumour is growing of a possible exemplary sanction against one of the big fund managers in Paris, which went before the enforcement committee at the end of 2024, whose decision has not been published, and whose boss has since stepped back, and gone abroad.