💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

Wild West

This one has been covered at length, because it made the headlines several times, so we won’t linger. But crypto is among the financial products with the shadiest marketing, pushed by a fair number of influencers who allow themselves just about anything.

A while ago I wrote about Polkadot, whose agency paid a whole bunch of people to promote the product without ever saying so (in French). According to a great many people in the industry, this is common practice. Even if several people told me that, in Polkadot’s case, it was more the personal initiative of a few individuals.

During the last bull run, NFTs were on everyone’s lips, and plenty of people got fleeced by projects that made no sense, pushed by people paid to promote them. A number of influencers with no link to crypto or finance were recently penalised: €150K from the DGCCRF, France’s consumer protection watchdog3, for Mohammed BDJ4, and €45K for TheKairi over another project that blew up a few weeks earlier5. Two cycles before that, reality TV star Nabilla Benattia-Vergara was fined €20K for promoting Bitcoin67. At the time of her ad, Bitcoin was trading at around $8K, against €100K today.

Around the same time, another former reality TV contestant, Julien Bert, launched Wolf’s Investment8, a so-called trading company that was in fact an affiliate platform, promising a 100% chance of making money. He was penalised in 2023 by the DGCCRF, but for other practices, notably disguised advertising. Asked about this by the French financial news outlet L’Agefi9, the French boss of the German neobroker Trade Republic said at the time:

That a line should be drawn between influencers who come from reality TV and content creators, who share their experience and good practice in finance without giving investment advice.

The complaints are always the same (though they don’t always come all at once):

  • The advertising is not declared;
  • The company being promoted is a scam;
  • The risks are not mentioned.

And yet other influencers in the crypto sphere never get called to order.

While some, like Hasheur, show real teaching skill and honesty, regularly explaining the risks of investing and how crypto works, that is not true of everyone.

Are 100% of the thousands of pieces of content Hasheur has published 100% compliant with the law and regulations? Probably not. But it is impossible to follow someone like that regularly without understanding the risks and the ins and outs.

That is not the case for many others who, for instance, openly share affiliate links to Bitget.

At the end of 2023, just a few weeks after the AMF’s announcement, the self-proclaimed “number one crypto newsletter in France”10, mocked several times by web3 professionals, was promoting Bitget as part of an ad for Oval3.

It is clearly stated that the piece is sponsored, but only the potential upsides are mentioned. Launched at $0.6, the token is now worth barely $0.001, a loss of more than 99% on around $2M invested. All the more problematic given that the newsletter in question is no stranger to misleading language and regularly uses the word “rich” to sell a training course. Like on 21 March 2022, when the issue titled “La DeFi te rend riche : les prêts à intérêt !” [DeFi makes you rich: interest-bearing loans!] explains lending. Caroline Jurado uses the example of Anchor and the Terra/Luna project.

The same newsletter explained how to get your first million euros with €300 a month.

A month later it all collapses and the token is down 96%.
It never recovered.
Caro did.

But not everyone gets the same treatment from the regulator.