💡 Who are these members piling up seats? How much do they earn? What are they for? An investigation.
Early this week, Amundi shook the world of SCPIs, France’s unlisted property funds sold to retail savers, by cutting the unit price of 3 of its funds by 15%. On Wednesday evening, BNP voted at a general meeting for a 17% cut in the unit price of Accimmo. I had raised this on LinkedIn a few weeks ago, and was told off by several professionals, even though the gap between unit price and reconstitution value (what it would cost to rebuild the portfolio) was getting dangerously close to its lower limit, and the market signals were strong.
READ ON LINKEDIN
👀 “SCPI : sous les pavés, la crise” [SCPIs: beneath the paving stones, the crisis]
👀 “Amundi : la chute spectaculaire” [Amundi: the spectacular fall]
Seeing that prices were not coming down, the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, had asked fund managers to value their portfolios. At a recent meeting of the ASPIM, the French trade body for property fund managers, attended by a very large number of managers, many lobbied to announce cuts after the summer, and ideally at the end of the year.
The aim? To have a reduced price on 1 January, in order to artificially inflate yields, since the AMF now requires the distribution yield to be calculated on the unit price at the start of the year, not during it.
At the very least, credit where it’s due: Amundi and BNP had the nerve to take the cut right now.

Because while some managers confine themselves (though always between -10% and +10%, obviously) to saying that commercial rents are index-linked to inflation, those rents have now been capped for 2 years.
Worse. With the slump in office property prices, some buildings have become completely illiquid, unsellable, even at a discount. A large fund manager cannot find a buyer at €40M for a building its flagship fund bought for €180M a few years ago. An offer of €20M is on the table.
But for this first newsletter (already followed by 450 of you: thank you 😎), I looked into another SCPI topic: supervisory boards.
It all started 3 months ago, while I was reading annual reports. Across 3 SCPIs I follow regularly, I found the same names on the supervisory boards. Digging a little, I learned that many people complain about these closed circles, which nobody understands and which don’t seem easy to join.
So I wanted to understand.
This investigation took several weeks and was particularly long. I went through the annual reports of the last 2 to 3 years of the 111 SCPIs open to new investors (so excluding tax-incentive funds), to extract the 1,047 names that make up their supervisory boards, then the budgets allocated to them. Then I interviewed around fifteen people: wealth advisers, fund managers and board members.
On the menu:
👉 A questionable role
👉 Serial seat-hoarders
👉 A shedload of cash
👉 And precious few women