A full analysis is hard because the reports differ so much. Mr Kontz says that 10 years ago he asked for the list of candidates, with their occupation and number of units, to be included in the annual report. That is now done, as at Amundi.
But sometimes it is much murkier. AEW gives only a list with no details. In its 2021 annual report, Aestiam states that all seats are up for renewal. Then confirms it in a quarterly bulletin without giving any details. A board regular points out that it is nonetheless on the ballot paper.
Yet it is particularly revealing. Let’s take a look at Valeur Pierre (BNP). End of 2022: 5 seats, 23 candidates. You can see why: the average attendance fee is equal to the yield on 182 units. The applicants own 192 units on average.
Except that SCPI income is taxed as property income (marginal income tax rate + 17.2% in social charges, so at least 40-50%), whereas attendance fees are subject to the flat tax, i.e. 30%.
EDIT 28 July 2023, 6.22pm: this statement is wrong. For some years now, the tax authorities have taxed attendance fees the same way as SCPI income, because they come from the same activity.
12 applicants out of 18 would earn more in attendance fees than in unit yield!
Same at Edissimo (Amundi): the individual applicants own 622 units on average (value: €127K), for around €4,500 in income. The €1,129 in attendance fees therefore amount on average to 25% of their income. Taking a rough average tax rate (marginal rate of 30%), it comes closer to 35% after tax.
At L'Oustal des Aveyronnais (Amundi), it is €81K in units for €2,284 in income, so an attendance fee of €354 that weighs in at 15% of their income.
Accès Valeur (BNP) attracts 23 candidates for 5 seats. While some names are starting to sound familiar, like Jean-Luc Bronsart and his 276 units, some are small holders with fewer than 50 units. Same picture at BNP’s other big payer of attendance fees, Accimmo: 26 candidates for 7 seats, with similar average holdings… and some candidates in common. The candidates’ average age is 61.
While there don’t seem to be any very small holders, or people who only buy a handful of units, a calculation across around ten SCPIs that disclose the number of units held by candidates shows an attendance fee worth between 20 and 30% in extra income (excluding expenses).
Asked about these large proportions, Mr Kontz agrees:
He says you could argue it isn’t normal, and that some SCPIs in fact require a minimum number of units to stand for the board.