As we have seen, some pay no attendance fees. That is the case of Groupama’s Affinité Pierre, which does not reimburse expenses either. Its board includes a retiree who invested €1,000, but also two Groupama entities:
A certain Eric Gelpe also sits in a personal capacity. This 54-year-old shareholder is not just anyone: the former CEO of the insurer GAN used to run the aforementioned Caisse.
The same goes for Thibault Delahaye, chairman of the board of Eurovalys, managed by Advenis IM, where he was… CEO for 13 years! He sits alongside Julien Ribes, head of MySCPI.com (who also sits at Sofidy Europe Invest).
Same story at Elysées Pierre (HSBC AM), where you find a former portfolio manager from the group, a former sales director and a current portfolio manager.
At Allianz Pierre, the chair is Allianz Vie, a sister company of the manager, Allianz Immovalor. The rest of the board, whose average age is 73, doesn’t look much more diverse. It includes Marcel Dehoux, an Allianz board regular, Socialist MP for the Nord département for 22 years, as well as a departmental councillor (17 years) and mayor (24 years). His local roots got him onto several boards of social housing bodies, such as Mon Abri and Habitat du Nord.
Nearly a third of the SCPIs analysed have people or companies on their board that are directly or indirectly linked to the fund manager. Probably more, since I was not able to analyse all 820 individuals and companies sitting on the boards.
I also found distributors (platforms, networks, etc., excluding insurers) and wealth advisers in nearly a quarter, without being able to be exhaustive. A presence that does not bother the board members I spoke to.
A major player in alternative distribution, for his part, confesses that he does not feel wanted:
He says fund managers are always a little reluctant to be seen openly with them.
He also mentions an unfair advantage that distributors and wealth advisers enjoy by motivating their clients to vote for them. Another, the boss of one of the big SCPI platforms, tells me he has been approached several times to sit on boards. His answer is clear-cut:
He says he refuses to sit on an SCPI supervisory board, and refuses to be a founding partner, because there is a major conflict of interest!
Others embrace it, like Raphaël Oziel. A wealth adviser who has worked at Sofidy and Linxea, he sits on 8 boards, including Activimmo’s:
He says he started out as an adviser, and that when you move up the ranks and are invited to join, you’re honoured!
His conflict of interest is generally disclosed. On Activimmo’s page, he writes:
He says he is among the founding partners of this SCPI and has the good fortune to be vice-chairman of its supervisory board, so he has seen it from the inside and can tell you your savings are in good hands. It is, he adds, one of his favourite SCPIs 🧡
His communications give no hint of any particular preference for one product. Better still: for him, displaying this prestige is a way of building his credibility. He admits that his sales are very low on some of the funds whose board he sits on. A former manager of a billion-euro SCPI says the same: according to him, wealth advisers use the board like a Légion d’honneur, France’s highest state decoration.
And while 8 seats may seem huge (and Mr Oziel admits he finds it rather time-consuming work), it is a far cry from the real specialists.