💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

The seat-hoarders

Among them, Mr Kontz. This 68-year-old former gendarme has been a board regular for 20 years.

He says he joined boards to keep an eye on his investments, that he is mainly in tax-incentive SCPIs, and that he is going to lose quite a few seats when they are wound up soon.

Indeed, Mr Kontz has sat or still sits on 25 tax-incentive SCPIs run by AEW, Allianz, BNP and La Française. Having been on the boards of Opus Real (BNP) and Crédit Mutuel Pierre 1 (La Française), he sits on France Investipierre (BNP) as chairman. Until Thursday, he was vice-chairman at Accimmo (BNP).

At the end of 2022, he also stood for the board of Cap Foncières & Territoires, then at Altixia Cadence XII and Epargne Pierre (Atland). Sandrine Kontz, who sits on the board of Ciloger 3 and 4, also stood at Selectipierre 2 (Fiducial).

Of the 111 SCPIs analysed, 15 other individuals currently hold at least 5 seats. Damien Vanhoutte, 72, sits on 4 La Française SCPIs and 4 Périal ones. Gérard Baudiffier, 65, is a Crédit Mutuel loyalist. Chairman of the board of his local branch, he sits on 5 SCPIs run by La Française, part of the Crédit Mutuel group. As does François Rincheval, who sits on 5 of the group’s SCPIs. Not counting tax-incentive funds.

Mr Cattin, for his part, sits on the boards of 8 SCPIs, 5 of them managed by La Française, and is standing at Cap Territoire, Pierre Capital (Swiss Life), Allianz Pierre and Pierre Plus (AEW):

He tells me he has acquired a taste for it: it takes up his time, but he enjoys it, and he does it the way he does on the town council where he sits, by working flat out.

But there are 2 champions: Olivier Blicq and his 13 seats, but above all Jean-Luc Bronsart and his 16 seats, or 14.4% of the SCPIs open to new investors!

This extreme seat-hoarding raises questions about their capacity, and their incentive, to supervise, especially when they collect almost as much in attendance fees as in rent!

Mr Blicq, for example, owns 10 units of Opportunité Immo, worth €2,030 and bringing in around €108 a year. With an attendance fee of around €1,050, that is 50% more income. At the end of 2022 he applied to the board of Logipierre 3, in which he holds 10 units (€16,000), for an attendance fee of around €430. In the management report of Crédit Mutuel Pierre 1, he states that he holds 17 current board seats in SCPIs.

Mr Bronsart, 68, is the all-round champion: 2 chairmanships and 3 vice-chairmanships. At the end of 2022, he applied to Accès Valeur Pierre (BNP), in which he holds 276 units (€231K), and declared a total of… 48 seats. Also applying: Jacques Morillon, 58, with 11 seats.

Of Mr Bronsart’s 16 seats in diversified SCPIs, I was able to piece together the breakdown of 8 investments: 1,926 units, valued at €1.178M, which brought in around €51,717 in 2022. He turns up in two SCPIs that pay no attendance fees (Grand Paris and Urban Coeur Commerce) and at Allianz Home, where the amount is not disclosed.

Mr Bronsart’s attendance fees can be estimated at around €25,840, the equivalent of 71 units of his average holding, for just 6 of the fifty or so seats he declared. In the SCPIs where his positions could be calculated, the fees amount on average to… 84% in extra income! At Opus Real (BNP), where his 7 units bring him €394, he receives 3.4x more in fees. It is 1.5x at Opportunité Immo (La Française), where his 68 units paid out €735 in 2022 against €1,136 in attendance fees, excluding expenses.

The rest of Mr Bronsart’s seats are in tax-incentive SCPIs, closed to new investors, which are not among the 111 funds on my initial list.

When contacted, Mr Blicq and Mr Bronsart did not respond.