Mr Bronsart, for example, chairs the board of Urban Pierre 3, which pays no attendance fees. But he also turns up in 3 AEW tax-incentive funds which, for their part, do pay them:
👉 Chairman of Ciloger Habitat 2 (Scellier, like the Duflot, Pinel, Robien and Borloo schemes below, a French buy-to-let tax break): €22,500, or €1,875 per person.
👉 Member of Ciloger Habitat 4 (Duflot): €13,500, or €1,125. He sits there alongside regulars such as Christian Bouthié.
👉 Member of Ciloger Habitat 5 (Pinel): €15,000, or €1,250. Chaired by Mr Bouthié.
👉 At Multihabitation 2, Mr Kontz is chairman and Mr Bronsart secretary. The 9 members share €9,000, among them François Rincheval, who sits on several La Française boards. And it is the same for the later versions.
👉 MH 3 (Robien): €9,000 between 9, with Mr Kontz as secretary, and Mr Rincheval still there.
👉 MH 4 (Borloo): this time Mr Bronsart chairs and Mr Kontz is a member, with Mr Rincheval. New twist: Mr Blicq is secretary! Still €1,000 per person.
👉 Along comes MH 5 (Scellier), and Mr Cattin becomes chairman, Mr Bronsart secretary. Mr Rincheval is still there, along with a raft of familiar names. Still the same budget.
👉 For MH 9, same again: Mr Cattin chairman, Mr Bronsart secretary, and Mr Blicq joins the party. New twist: only €6,000 in attendance fees.
If I don’t mention the other MH funds, it’s because Mr Bronsart isn’t on them: but the others are, of course. And it is the same (with the same crowd) at Rénovimmo (La Française, €9,000), Résidence Patrimoine (AEW, €10,000, with Mr Bouthié), Atout Pierre Habitation 2 (AEW, €9,000, with Mr Kontz) and Fructirésidence (AEW, €10,000, with Mr Bouthié), etc.
Everyone admits that tax-incentive funds take up less time. Mr Kontz in fact regrets that all the properties have already been bought when subscriptions open. But Ms Karsenty insists that a diversified SCPI is a lot of work.
Can the seat-hoarders do an effective and independent job?
Opinions differ. Several managers who have dealt with these people describe them as influential, constructive, loudmouths, eloquent.
A wealth adviser tells me Jean-Luc Bronsart is the most eloquent in board meetings, but that he and the others really do bring something to the table.
Other sources mention members for whom the outline of the report is sometimes written for them, and who simply sign it. A close observer remarks that Mr Kontz is starting to kick against the traces. Before adding:
According to him, most of the time there is no work: they turn up, put their feet under the table, and that’s that.
That may be why board members are often elderly. One regular sees it this way:
He points out that someone still working has to take half a day off to attend a general meeting, which is fine once or twice…
Several professionals see it as the residents’ committee syndrome: the oldest, who have more time, keep busy and get into the details, while others are happy to have it done for them.