💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 10

Deeds not words!

Only 14% of the world’s large financial institutions are run by women. While Société Générale and Crédit Agricole have a woman among their top executives, there are none at BNP or Crédit Mutuel. The figures for the executive committees of the CAC 40 and SBF 120, France’s main stock market indices, showed that the most common way to raise the share of women was not to replace men… but to make executive committees bigger. No major French bank is run by a woman.

SCPIs are no exception. First, because women are a minority among investors and in finance, where they make up less than 25% of the workforce. Worse: they are concentrated in HR (58% women), compliance (34%) and marketing (46%).1 In fund management roles, it is 17%. Anne Rabant is the exception at Amundi: SCPIs are a blokes’ business! And it shows on the boards.

Of 1,047 board seats, 108 are held by women (10.3%), but only 78 (7.4%) by individuals, the others being representatives of companies.

At Aestiam, it is 3 women for 34 seats. The same at AEW, but for 114 members! 1 in 58 at Amundi. 0 in 25 at Atland. 7 in 65 at BNP. 3 in 69 at Fiducial. 8 in 106 at La Française. 3 in 62 at PAREF. 2 in 45 at Primonial. Only Sofidy does better, with 10 in 56.

👉 The average is 0.76 women per board

👉 51 SCPIs have no women on their board

👉 More than half of the women (42) sit on just 16 SCPIs

Among them is Inter Gestion, which stands out as an example with 2 SCPIs where 4 of the 7 members are women. Only Sofipierre (Sofidy) comes close, with 40%, followed by Optimale (Consultim) at 33%.

Mr Kontz prefers to zoom out:

He says there were far fewer in 2020, and that more and more women are applying.

Another interesting finding: the bigger the SCPI, the fewer women there are, as this breakdown chart shows.

That raises serious questions about the SCPIs claiming the ISR label, France’s socially responsible investment label, which is about half the funds. ESG Pierre Capitale (Swiss Life), which went as far as putting its commitment in its name, manages to have no women among its 8 members. Its report opens with HIS chairman, and HIS manager. On the management board of the fund manager sits 1 woman out of 5 members (marketing). On the same company’s supervisory board sits 1 woman out of 8.