Board members can be paid for their work (attendance fees) and have their expenses covered.
In 2022, 71 SCPIs disclosed whether or not they paid attendance fees, for a total of €1,152,339: €16,230 on average, or €1,688 per member. Only 7 SCPIs say they pay none, including Log In.
Ms Hellegouarch of Theoreim explains that they don’t take people with too many seats, that they set an age limit, and that they chose not to pay attendance fees.
On top of that come €455,685 in expenses that I was able to trace. But most SCPIs don’t disclose the amounts reimbursed.
AEW, for example, separates fees from expenses: across its 10 SCPIs, an average of €24,800 in attendance fees and €11,838 in expenses.
At Allianz Pierre, you get a single line, “Rapports annuels, publicité légale et jetons de présence” [Annual reports, legal notices and attendance fees]. The bill was €72,219 in 2020, €95,348 in 2021 and €117,815 in 2022. An increase of 63% in 2 years, with no explanation.
The payout, meanwhile, fell -1.25%, and the unit price -1.31% over the same period.
Its board found nothing to object to.
Is that really reasonable?
While Corum sets its attendance fees at €4,000, Épargne Foncière (La Française), the largest fund on the market by capitalisation, offers €67,125. It is €57,000 at BNP for Accès Valeur and Accimmo, and €50,000 at AEW for Fructipierre and Laffitte. Figures that seem to track the size of the SCPI, as shown by this distribution of attendance fees (excluding expenses) against capitalisation (in €M).
They have been rising steadily for years.
At Fructipierre (AEW), it was €22,360 in 2020 and €22,555 in 2019. It is €50,000 in 2022. That is a 122% increase. Over the same period, the yield fell by 5.88%.
Same story at Laffitte (AEW): the attendance fees went from €30,000 to €50,000 over 3 years, while the unit price fell by 37% and the yield by 1%. In its report written in 2022, the board expressed surprise at low inflows, but stated that the intrinsic qualities of the SCPI were not in question, and even spoke of the stability of its portfolio in terms of valuation.
In reality, the vast majority of boards never question the manager’s decisions.
Relative to SCPI units, the fees are huge!
👉 12 SCPIs (including 3 from La Française and 3 from BNP) pay more than €2,500 per person: €5,181 at Accimmo (BNP), €4,475 at Épargne Foncière (La Française). It reaches €7,110 at Pierre Plus (AEW) in cost to shareholders, once you add expenses.
👉 On average, the attendance fees are worth the price of 4.4 units of the SCPI: 25 at Accimmo (BNP), 14 at France Investipierre (BNP), 11 at Efimmo (Sofidy) and 10 at Immorente (Sofidy).
👉 On average, the attendance fees are worth the yield of 114 units: 665 at Accimmo (BNP), 295 at Investipierre (BNP) and 600 at Sofiprime (Sofidy)
Conversely, with a unit price of €15,300, the €12,000 in attendance fees at Immo Evolutif are worth only 0.1 unit and 2.2 units’ worth of yield. All the less of an issue given that you need at least 50 units (€765K) to be a shareholder.
Inevitably, the 23 SCPIs you can buy into for under €1,500 hint at a possible problem: they offer 5 times the minimum investment and 130 times the minimum yield.
Are the elected members in it (only) for the money?