In 2013, after a long conflict between the supervisory boards of Cifocoma 1 and 2 and Uffi Ream (long run by Frédéric Puzin before he founded Corum), the SCPI moved to Sofidy.
Between 2011 and 2012, Uffi was looking for a buyer. The SCPIs’ coffers were full, according to a board member at the time. So the managers set about buying rubbish to make their management look good, he says. Uffi was bought by Fiducial in July 2012.
At Sofidy, things did not improve. Several shareholders explain that the manager struggled to sell assets without a loss, and kept buying underperforming properties. The secretary of the ASPPSCPI, an association representing savers, called Ms Karsenty, a strong-minded woman who had already taken an SCPI away from BNP. She took the chair of Cifocoma 2, and Charles Coulon that of Cifocoma 1.
Ms Karsenty explains that, at the time, they had left with Uffi threatening to sue.
At the end of 2016, Sofidy asked for the SCPI’s articles to be changed, because the manager had to seek the board’s agreement on most decisions, notably buying and selling assets. The partners voted against on 6 December. Two weeks later, Sofidy resigned its management mandate.
In March 2017, Xavier Parrain, then secretary general of the AMF, met the 2 chairmen. The AMF replied that selling assets is a management act. And so outside the board’s remit.
Ms Karsenty regrets that the AMF did not accept their articles, which were highly protective of the partners.
On 1 June, Paref was appointed as successor amid intense confusion: several board members sent petitions calling for the fund to be wound up.
Which is what eventually happened in 2020. In a final letter, the board concluded:
The board writes that a merger had been on the agenda since its arrival in October 2017, but that after study, this sensible path had proved too costly given the current state of the SCPI.
These very hands-on boards are what has been holding back Novapierre Allemagne for years. While the website La Centrale des SCPI says the product fell victim to its own success, above all it fell victim to its board. For months, the board members fought a capital increase, for fear of slightly eroding performance. The big holders make themselves heard. The manager gives in, closes the fund to new money and opens Novapierre Allemagne 2.
Someone close to the matter says, bitterly:
According to him, the board members blocked the fund, for their own personal interests.