SCPI managers often explain that their interests are aligned with savers’: if they win, everyone wins. That is mostly untrue.
Fund managers are named in the SCPI’s articles of association. To change manager, you have to change the articles. Their mandate is not renewed, unlike the supervisory board’s, or that of the managing agent of a block of flats, for example.
Yet it is the same thing, Ms Karsenty argues: their job is to manage assets that don’t belong to them, on behalf of people who clubbed together to buy them.
Broadly speaking, savers make money in 2 ways:
Fund managers, meanwhile, pile up the fees. Take Épargne foncière (La Française), the biggest on the market:
In recent years, SCPIs have raised record amounts. Even 2023, rotten as it is, will rank in the all-time top 10 for inflows. That money (€10bn in 2022) has to be spent! Because those inflows are mostly new units, and so extra yield to be paid out.
That is the whole problem of recent years.
A former BNP Real Estate employee told me how a young SCPI set up 4 years ago spent hundreds of millions while being led up the garden path by the developer, who offloaded what nobody else wanted. Inside the fund manager itself, people admit, off the record and between the lines, that the portfolio is poor.
Not only are the managers’ interests not aligned with the partners’, but above all, the supervisory board is purely advisory.
Mr Kontz says it is a shame the board doesn’t have more power over management, since the assets belong to the partners, before lamenting that partners give their proxy to the fund manager rather than to the board’s chairman.
A view shared by every board member I spoke to.