💥 Zero Bullshit

SCPIs: a multi-billion-euro debacle

A quarter of funds marked down, more than half of total capitalisation hit

Last June, ASPIM, the lobby group for French property fund managers, sent out its newsletter. Its chairman, Jean-Marc Coly, opens the letter by telling readers he is delighted.1

A bill of several billion euros left to the savers in SCs, OPCIs and SCPIs (France’s unlisted property funds, sold to ordinary investors), but Jean-Marc Coly is delighted.

Further out than an Apollo mission. 🚀

A few months earlier, in a press release2, he said:

that managers had shown transparency and responsiveness.

A line that echoes the words picked up in September 2023 by my fellow journalist Gaétan Pierret of L’Agefi, a French financial news outlet3, when Coly praised the courage of the managers who were cutting their share prices, conveniently forgetting that they were doing so after the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, asked for property valuations to be updated. Something a good many managers put off for months, for as long as they possibly could.

Further down the letter, we even learn that yields are said to be holding steady. Except the IRR (internal rate of return) is very largely negative, especially for offices, at -9.1%.

So, 18 months after the crisis began, where are we now?

You can also make a donation here. It’s up to you, and best of all there’s no Substack taking 10% and no Stripe taking 3% 😅.

Illustration from the newsletter “SCPIs: a multi-billion-euro debacle”

EDIT 11/10/24 10:50: several tables and charts use Datawrapper. They seem to display incorrectly in emails and rather badly on mobile. They look best on desktop, but the charts can also be clicked.