💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Rock ’n’ Roll Suicide

On the other hand, the SCPIs shaking the most aren’t just any SCPIs.

First, let’s put the number in context. Over the past 18 months, 31 SCPIs have tumbled7. I see plenty of players downplaying it by saying it’s 31 out of 216. But that’s wrong. It’s 31 out of 105, the rest being tax-incentive SCPIs, about which we know very little and which may well suffer even more. That makes 29% of funds which, before the crisis, represented more than 60% of capitalisation.

The markdowns are anything but trivial: 16 SCPIs have fallen by more than 10%, 9 of which have had 2 to 3 markdowns, with BNP taking the prize for a -31.2% on Accimmo Gravel and its three markdowns in less than a year. Well done.8

Incidentally, BNP being there is no accident either. Because these 31 markdowns come from only 12 managers:

  • Advenis (1)
  • AEW (7), formerly BPCE/La Poste, now Natixis (Caisse d’Épargne, Banque Populaire)
  • Amundi (3), Crédit Agricole
  • BNP (3)
  • Fiducial (2)
  • HSBC (1)
  • La Française (3), Crédit Mutuel Alliance Fédérale
  • Paref (1)
  • Perial (4)
  • Primonial/Praemia (3)
  • Sofidy (2)
  • Unofi (1)

So of the 31 markdowns, 17 come from managers owned by banking groups.

But they share another feature: most of them were very big fundraisers between 2018 and 2022.

Table shamelessly nicked from PierrePapierCiseau

The only ones missing are Avenis, Fiducial, HSBC, Paref and Unofi, in other words… those with only one SCPI in the markdown ranking (except Fiducial, which has one).

Hard not to see a link… but which one?