One of the most striking and emblematic examples is of course Primopebble. It’s also interesting because, unlike its pals, this SCPI wasn’t sold on a massive scale through a bank branch network. In 2022, the SCPI reported €3.9bn of capitalisation, against €3.6bn the year before. Net inflows were €249M.
And at that point, Primonial must have remembered the words of that great hip-hop philosopher:
“Mo money, mo problems.”
Because, as we saw earlier, inflows cost money when they aren’t invested. Conversely, thanks to the waiting period, between 1 and 6 months (usually 3) during which the investor receives nothing, the manager can either cushion the drag of the cash… or simply keep some of the return for itself if the money is invested sooner.
In 2022, Primonial made 3 acquisitions, for a total of €403M. Yes: €134M on average. A former employee tells me the reason bluntly, one that in fact everyone already knows.
The bigger the inflows, he says, the longer it takes to deploy them. Buying a €100M building or a €10M one takes the same time. But buying 10 buildings at €10M takes 10 times longer than one at €100M.
Indeed. So much for diversification. Especially since Primoshingle was then 30% offices in Paris, 58% offices in the Paris region and 11% offices in the rest of France. In its annual report, the manager was keen to reassure, even though prices had already started to fall.
Nexxt Gambetta was bought through yet another opaque SCI (a French property holding company) about which nothing is known, except that in 2023, the SCPI put more than €160M into it as a shareholder loan. Between 2022 and 2023, the estimated value of the stake went from €40.2M to… €165K. 🥳
Sensorium, bought for €123M, was valued at €29M in 2023.
The consequences for investors are pretty brutal.
To see it, just look at the performance of Primorubble since its launch. Take an investor who puts in €1,000 and then stays put, which is consistent with the 10-year investment horizon, but above all with the reality that shares are held for more than 20 years.
You can see that on average it takes 2-3 years for the payouts to make up for the 10.77% entry fees. But above all, you can see that everyone who invested since 2015… will still be losing money in 2025.9 As for the others, their maximum IRR is 1.8%.
Enough to make some of the salespeople’s arguments look very dated.
Some investments such as SCPIs have advantages, because they are inflation-linked, according to Moniwan
The SCPI is one of the only investments indexed to inflation, according to France SCPI
The situation is clearly not about to improve, since Praemia told its distributors this week that a fall in rates would have only a limited impact, and above all a very gradual one.
This big-ticket buying strategy (€55M at LastOfPierre) can be found at quite a few competitors: Accès Valeur Pierre (€26M), Edissimmo (€19M), Lafitte Pierre (€14M), Eurovalys (€32M), Europimmo (€23M), Grand Paris Patrimoine (€32M), Notapierre (€20M), Opus Real (€32M), Rivoli Avenir (€19M), PFO2 (€15M).
At Corum, it’s between €15M and €20M depending on the SCPI, while Iroko, Remake and ActivImmo are below €10M. Their youth obviously plays a part: these SCPIs raised less, and didn’t have as much to deploy. But two heads of management firms told me plainly that it was a deliberate strategy.
Last year Pierre-Antoine Burgala even owned this strategy for Iroko , which he likened to chicken coops 🐔
Iroko, he said, wants to be granular: it champions ultra-diversification and the dilution of risk, and sees flexibility as a major strength.