💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Space Oddity

The symbol of these reckless, outdated and lavish choices: the Cœur Défense tower, which I mentioned in a newsletter about the SCIs hidden inside SCPIs (in French), then in a LinkedIn post where I pointed to an unrealised loss of €600M.

A gigantic pile of cash with which you could have funded the loss-making Ÿnsect for more than 10 years (in French)! 😚

We also learn in passing that the 8.55% of the Cœur Défense tower, which I’ve mentioned here several times, bought for €80M by Primopierre, are now worth less than €31M. From which we can deduce that Cœur Défense’s valuation has gone from €935M10 to barely €360M.

Quite a deal, completely opaque, through an SCI nobody knows anything about, also backed by Amundi and Crédit Agricole Assurances. The exact financing of the deal has never been disclosed, not even to the investors in the funds that own up to 20% of the complex. But this summer, CFNews Immo revealed that nearly €900M had been refinanced, in a deal led by Natixis11 , confirmed by Bavaria’s public state bank 2 months later.12

Enough to call into question the reassuring line from Praemia’s management, which explains that its leverage is perfectly beneficial since it was signed at very low rates. I somehow doubt the €900M was refinanced at 1%.

The problem is that, like everywhere in La Défense, Paris’s main business district, the tower is hard to let, all the more so as it is ageing badly and works would be very expensive. And it’s not the vague plan for a terrace that’s going to change the game…

It’s still offices. In La Défense.