Calculating a yield isn’t very complicated: even a SoftBank VC could do it. It’s a ratio between the amount invested and the amount paid out (that’s the second time I’ve said it, we’ll end up knowing it by heart). For an SCPI, the amount paid out is obviously the money paid per share. As for the share price… well, that’s not simple. In fact the calculation has changed several times, taking the price of a share at a given point in the year, then an average. Except that, obviously, this is relevant to nobody, unless you invested in the first few months.4
If I invest in 2020 at €100 a share, and my manager pays out €5 a year, my yield is 5%. But if the share goes up to €105 and the manager pays out €5, the published yield will be 4.76%, while mine is, in reality, still 5%, since I did invest €100.
Take Accimmo. As an example, OK, put that subscription form down5. In 2021, at the peak of inflows, I invest €205 for 1 share, which earns me €9.36 (4.56%). In 2022 the payout drops to €7.8 (3.8%), then €7.2 in 2023 (3.5%). In September 2024, the share falls to €141, so for the same payout, the published yield would be… 5.1%.
Most SCPIs that have slaughtered their share price will therefore end up with artificially inflated yields, which will probably, by the way, push up the average yield that had been stuck around 4.4% for a few years.
Including for SCPIs that are going to cut their payout. In 2021, Primopierre (pierre is French for stone) paid out €9.93 on a share priced at €208 (4.8%). The payout was brought down to €8.56 last year, but the forecast (confidential, but hey, here’s the info) from Praemia6 is to pay out around €6 for 2025 and 2026. A headline yield of… 4.8%. When in reality, those who came in before 2022 will receive 2.9%, on top of having lost 40% of their investment.
Enough to revive inflows? Obviously not, and at Praemia as elsewhere it obviously won’t be a selling point. A Praemia executive talks of at least three to four years before any hope of inflows returning to Primopebble.