Inevitably, this brings us back to the eternal question of conflicts of interest. Who stands to gain what?
Praemia is telling its distributors that it will launch a major plan to restructure the assets of Primorollingstonegathersnorent, covering at least 20% of the floor space. Obviously, they’ll stuff themselves with fees on the works… and that’s a good thing!
Because for the first time, managers on the edge of the abyss can no longer count on what has kept them fed for years: subscription fees. All those stuck with run-down portfolios, overflowing with assets nobody wants, have to add value, improve, restructure and sell. Good. That’s what savers pay for. That’s an asset manager’s job.
That’s the whole point of SCPIs with no entry fees, which many people criticise using sales pitches written by the established managers. And yet taking fees on works, capital gains and so on aligns the interests of managers and savers far more than the subscription fee, which weighs on the investment’s performance for its entire life.
And of course, when you talk about fees, you can’t ignore the role of intermediaries, especially CGPs and CIFs (France’s financial advisers). After writing about the subject so often, I’ve received several accounts from people who invested in SCPIs in 2022 (through an adviser), including 4 who subscribed at the end of 2022 to 3 SCPIs that tumbled a few months later.
How can a serious professional have recommended such bad investments?
Because these giants had already invested massively in overpriced assets, were starting to suffer from vacancies, had an offering out of step with what the market wanted, and rates were already rising.
But then, what can you expect from a profession whose main trade body (Anacofi) went all the way to France’s Constitutional Council to demand that commissions on sales of Pinel properties (a French buy-to-let tax-break scheme) be allowed to exceed… 10%.1314 And in which less than 5% are paid by fees rather than commissions.
Same goes for the media covering financial investments that hand out awards like a school sports day where everyone gets a medal (for €3,000 to €6,000 a year to display it).
Award for Primoshingle in 2021. Even Voldemort had a better nose.
The whole of late 2022 was marked by a surprising reassurism in the media, like the business daily Les Echos, which found that SCPIs were holding up, even though no performance figures had come out yet, quoting an expert who explained that the momentum for investing in SCPIs was rather good. 15 The article was picked up almost word for word by Le Figaro a few days later.16 Meanwhile L’Agefi relayed a distributor’s superb inflow figures17 without the slightest critical distance, before launching a fierce attack on SCPIs with no entry fees using the usual (false) arguments.18
In November 2022, as rates were exploding, Investissements Conseils, a trade magazine for advisers, wondered whether it was still worth investing in offices.19 After being rather reassuring while presenting the changes under way, the article ended with a selection of eight SCPIs.
Six of these investments would collapse in the following months. Nice performance.
Same story a month earlier for Le Figaro, which drew up a ranking in which 50% of the score came from the outlook20. While first place, with 16/20, went to Épargne Pierre, the rest of the ranking was a horoscope column x Nostradamus
While early 2023 would bring more caution and less focus on individual funds, it would take until the height of summer and the first share price cuts for the media to really get to grips with the subject of the assets themselves.