💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Heroes

Not a single manager or financial intermediary has taken the slightest loss in 2 years. For savers, it runs into billions, and that still doesn’t include those stuck waiting while their capital keeps shrinking every 6 months.

Some heads have rolled. And 2024 could see the first SCPI go bust. At least two major funds are facing bullet loans (repaid in one go at maturity) for which they don’t have enough cash, and whose amount exceeds the value of the asset. That said, banks are being accommodating on refinancing. An expert explains why to me:

No bank, he says, wants a default worth tens of millions on its books. And above all, no bank wants to seize a rotten, unsellable property that nobody wants.

Once again, it’s the savers who will lose.

Still, some managers are doing the job, and I want to point that out, since I mostly write about the negative stuff.

  • Kyaneos Pierre, and its string of Denormandie properties (a French tax scheme for renovating old rental housing), which are doing well, and let you invest in residential property with a real social impact;
  • Corum, whose fall many former managers predicted at the first market downturn. The marketing is aggressive, but the results are there;
  • Iroko Zen and its incredible momentum, which has managed to establish the model of the SCPI with no subscription fee (and not no fees, as some say);
  • Remake Live, Novaxia Neo, which followed in dropping subscription fees;
  • Transition Europe, perfectly launched by Arkea, even if they fiddle things a bit to show a yield of more than 8%;
  • Log In from Theoreim, which on top of having a cool name keeps showing (and beating) a 5% yield;
  • And also Cristal Rente, Affinités Pierre and Epsilon 360, which raised their share price, thumbing their nose at the market.

All the more so as some of these SCPIs, and others which, even if they don’t necessarily have an incredible aura, are still well below their value and deserve a closer look: Opportunité Immo (-10%), Epsilon 360 (-8%), Cristal Life (-8%), Iroko Zen (-4%), Atream Hotels (-4%), Épargne Pierre (-5%), etc.

Obviously, they all have different strategies, with different results, and as the saying goes, past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. What’s more, my paragraph is not investment advice (the earlier ones, on the other hand, are clearly non-investment advice).

But looking at the numbers, it is very clear that the SCPI market is dead. In the same way that talking about the property market in France doesn’t make much sense.

We are in a two-speed system. Not only on yield, not only on fees, but in terms of managers that are more agile, understand the changes and want to do things differently.

Not just because the numbers are heading the right way. Investing at more than 5% with no risk doesn’t exist. And maybe some of them will lose people money. That comes with any investment. But the philosophy itself is different.

It’s no accident that these players aren’t owned by banking groups. And it’s probably no accident that the only bank hanging around is Arkea, which (a long, long time ago) knew how to make the most of fintech innovation.

A few days ago, the Cannes Film Festival of dosh took place at Patrimonia, the wealth advisers’ trade convention. The theme was “Prendre sa place dans un métier pour l'avenir, se différencier pour réussir” [Taking your place in a profession for the future, standing out to succeed].

What if standing out meant turning resolutely towards savers, and not just towards commissions?

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I advise finance, property and web3 companies on branding, positioning and content creation.

👉 Contact me, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Send me a brief for a professional project

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to present a project or a service (€250 per call)

You can also make a donation here. It’s up to you, and best of all there’s no Substack taking 10% and no Stripe taking 3% 😅.