SCPIs combine problems built into their model with macro problems, which can be sorted into 3 categories.
After Covid, everyone believed the office was finished. Yet many managers claimed the asset class had nothing to fear, and that hot-desking would at most mean smaller floor space. Then that they would go “service-led”. Except… nothing was done.
Since I was working for one of these managers at the time, I saw the huge gap between talk of changing ways of working and redesigned spaces… and a company doing everything it could to get its teams back into the office as fast as possible.
Hard to imagine that people who didn’t really believe their own talk anticipated this shift in demand. All the more so because restructuring these buildings is expensive and takes time.
The fact remains that by 2023, very little had been done. And while Covid had hit hotels hard and boosted logistics and healthcare, those values are drifting back towards some kind of normal. But not offices bought too expensively.
The period 2018-2021 brought record years of inflows for managers. That money had to be spent to keep yields up. Because almost all the big SCPIs are variable-capital funds. So if the money coming in isn’t invested, and therefore earns nothing, there’s a risk of lowering the payout per share.
Many management firms found themselves competing for assets worth tens or even hundreds of millions. With prices already rising, they played an active part in that inflation. Just as along came…
Except that 2022 brought inflation. Some will say the war in Ukraine caused it, when we know that the real underlying problem is the massive injection of capital into the market and huge money creation.
It’s extremely obvious in property, by the way, where residential prices and volumes are entirely tied to interest rates; I wrote a newsletter about it (in French).
In fact, rates could never stay at 0%. If only because during the Covid crisis, central banks should have cut their rates to revive the economy, but couldn’t… since they had been at 0% since 2016.
(I talked about it here and here and a bit here)
The only question was: when?
And the arrival of inflation should have given everyone the answer.
When darling Chrichri, our pet name for the head of the European Central Bank, announced a first rate rise on a summer’s day in 2022, there was no world in which rates could stay at that level. Even if, admittedly, such a sudden rise was hard to predict.
But from that moment, it was obvious that commercial property prices were going to fall, because of risk premiums that every manager knows well.
I won’t go through it all again, everyone knows it, and for anyone passing through by chance, I explained it here. But in short: when the return on risk-free investments rises (which happens with rates), those who take risks raise the return they’re after by as much, to keep their risk premium. Since a yield is a basic ratio between income and the amount invested, and rents aren’t very flexible, it’s prices that adjust.
So the more rates rise, the more asset values fall.
The problem is that in the second half of 2022, some managers kept investing as if prices hadn’t changed. Partly, but not only, because these are fairly long deals. It’s also what killed Masteos (in French), by the way.