💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 11

Diamond Dogs

Take Épargne Foncière in 2022, the 3rd-biggest fundraiser, and the largest capitalisation at the time. La Française takes 10% of rents, and 7.5% of subscriptions. That comes to €15.8M for management and €55M for subscriptions. Disposals brought in only €2M and works €800K. So what pays La Française is: inflows.

Inevitably, you find the same bias at all the big fundraisers, in every variable-capital SCPI.

Of course SCPIs with no entry fees charge higher management fees, works fees and so on. But that forces them to do a real asset manager’s job, where survival doesn’t depend on inflows alone.

Even if part of the subscription fees goes towards paying distributors.

But what is a manager for, if it doesn’t actively manage its portfolio and has no vision for the future?

Because the global market has not been through a property crisis. Unlike what France went through in the 1990s, this is a rebuilding of the risk premium, and therefore a fall in prices, following the rise in rates.

In other words, the fundamentals are not affected. Residential property, incidentally, reacted very differently. Since private buyers aren’t focused on yield, and demand is very tight, prices took a while to fall, and fell less. So much so, in fact, that the market will probably start rising again as soon as rates fall, and that this will end up being a problem, given how far prices have drifted from both wages and inflation.

Obviously, this is a change of cycle, and so offices are reinventing themselves. But that’s precisely what you expect from a manager. Not that it predicts the future, but that it anticipates it, and adapts along with it.

And that’s also what you’re entitled to expect from the financial intermediaries who advise investors.

How do you explain that in Q1 2023, more than 6 months after rates started rising, AEW, Primonial and BNP were among the top fundraisers?

Who advised savers to stick nearly €60M into Primograinofsand after reading its latest quarterly reports, which were frankly disastrous?

Either the intermediaries who advised these investments didn’t understand what they were recommending, and that’s serious. Or they did understand, and that’s serious.