Why does France’s crowdfunding licence, the PSFP, need an urgent rethink?
A few days ago, the boss of a big asset management firm asked me why I write newsletters.
Not to find clients. My daily nonsense is enough for that. Nobody finds me twice as interesting or relevant because I write the long version of an analysis.
Not to make money. Zero Bullshit has cost me more in legal proceedings (€12.5K) than it brings in (€11.8K). And spending 1 or 2 days writing an issue is clearly not profitable. Even if the ads help, these days.
Not for fame. Even with 74,000 subscribers (thank you, by the way), a newsletter doesn’t get likes or comments.
Maybe for fun. I admit I love getting into complicated subjects, digging, and above all finding. It’s no cooler than horse riding or lawn bowls.
But mostly because I believe in it. I love savings. I love savers. I love imagining them making informed decisions. I love believing we can offer them investments that are useful and worthwhile for them. Even though I’ve seen from the inside how rotten the system is, because of the many people who think only about their marketing or their fees, and how overall it never benefits ordinary investors.
And yet, that’s not entirely true. There are plenty of companies, big and small, offering cool solutions, and those are the ones I want to work with. And telling my nonsense here or on LinkedIn shows them that our opinions are aligned.
Still, crowdfunding (a bit like SCPIs, France’s retail property funds) is a subject I’ve covered regularly for 3 years. I warned about the royalties of Bricks, a French property crowdfunding platform, as early as 2022. Then about their fundraising. Then about the coming reversal of the crowdfunding market at the end of 2022, then of SCPIs in early 2023. Commercially, it was completely stupid. Several of these players could have been my clients.
Today I don’t really have the heart to say “I told you so”. Because the people paying are still not the ones responsible. Not the intermediaries. Not the operators. Not the regulators. Not the journalists. Not me, for that matter. It’s tens and tens of thousands of ordinary savers who are going to be fleeced of a billion euros because of crowdfunding. After losing several billion because of certain SCPIs.
Anyway, I think that’s why I write Zero Bullshit. And to carry that commitment, I’ll make an announcement at the end of this newsletter (major tease).
Conflicts of interest
Conflict of interest disclaimer: directly or indirectly, I have also been paid to work for several players in crowdfunding and equity crowdfunding, including some mentioned in this newsletter.