💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

The bricks-and-mortar illusion

In France, crowdfunding very quickly took a huge turn towards property (savers lending, through bonds, to property developers), which is much less the case in other European countries, and which explains why crowdfunding as a whole is suffering from an over-concentration in this asset class. For several years, it was presented as an alternative to buy-to-let, a way of investing in property without the hassle of managing it. This line was widely repeated by the media, which took up the platforms’ own words. Not necessarily because the players wanted to lie, but because it was a simple way of presenting the investment. Especially when, at the end of 2022, the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, called time on the royalties free-for-all, and the bond became the norm: supposedly enough to make investors safe.

Even today, Bricks still puts this message out:

Koregraf too:

As does La Première Brique :

And yet, it’s false.

At no point does the saver invest in property: their money finances a small business carrying out a property deal. Which changes absolutely everything.

The first reason is that the property doesn’t belong to the savers, and that while a security is sometimes taken over the property… it doesn’t necessarily guarantee the money.

To convince yourself, you only need to calculate 3 fairly simple ratios.

  • LTV (Loan To Value), which assesses the risk relative to the value of the property when the project ends. This ratio focuses solely on the value of the property itself, without taking into account additional costs (notary fees, works, etc.);
  • LTA (Loan To Acquisition) , which assesses the risk of the amount borrowed relative to the initial purchase cost of the property. This ratio focuses on the profitability of the purchase itself, before any transformation.
  • LTC (Loan To Cost), which measures the risk relative to the total cost of the project, including the purchase, fees, works and other costs. It is the most complete ratio, because it takes into account all the spending needed to carry out a property project

Loan To Value

The aim is to assess whether the value of the property is enough to cover the whole debt in the event of a forced sale or financial difficulty.

The ratio only takes into account the value of the property at purchase or at the end of the project. It ignores side costs such as notary fees or works. As a result, a high LTV (>80%) can be risky if the property’s value doesn’t rise as expected or if the property market turns.

💡Let’s say a property is bought for 100, and a loan of 90 is taken out to finance the purchase.

LTV = 90 ÷ 100 = 90%.
This means that 90% of the property’s value is financed by borrowing. If the property’s value falls, say to 80% of its initial value, the ratio becomes too risky. This ratio ignores other costs, such as works or financing costs, which can be underestimated.

Loan To Acquisition

This ratio is crucial for assessing the profitability of buying the property itself, before any transformation or renovation, because it mainly measures borrowing relative to the purchase value of the property. A high LTA indicates that the loan is large compared with the price paid for the property, which increases the risk if the loan exceeds the purchase price. It is often used for property projects that aim to buy cheap, renovate and sell on.

💡 Let’s say a property is acquired for 100, and a loan of 120 is taken out to finance the purchase.

LTA = 120 ÷ 100 = 120%.
In this case, the loan exceeds the purchase cost. That can be risky if the purchase price was already high given the state of the property, because the financing exceeds the value of the acquisition.

Loan To Cost

This ratio gives a complete view of the overall financing needed to carry out a property project, by measuring the risk against the total cost of the project, which includes items often underestimated in LTV and LTA, such as works or extra costs. This ratio is crucial for renovation or property development projects, where construction or works costs can be high relative to the purchase price.

💡Let’s say the total cost of the project, including purchase, fees and works, is 150, and a loan of 120 is taken out to finance it.

LTC = 120 ÷ 150 = 80%.

Here, the ratio shows that 80% of the project’s total cost is financed by borrowing. This ratio matters because it reflects not only the purchase of the property, but also the refurbishment or construction costs, which can be riskier to finance.

Surprisingly, this ratio has never become standard on the platforms, even though it is a very important indicator, but the ratios are obviously calculated by the various players, even if they’re not the only factors. In any case, it helps you understand why taking security over a property is not simple. Especially since not all guarantees are equal, and they’re not easy to put in place.

What’s more, by compiling the ratios across different platforms, you realise that some took much bigger risks than others.

Sounds complicated? That’s normal, it is. In fact, the whole spirit of the regulation is to let the platforms decide which projects they will finance.

But that’s also the whole problem.