💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 05

The institutional lock

Granted, the CAPSSA vs HEM case was not directly linked to a crowdfunding platform. But the case law set by the Cour de cassation would apply directly to these platforms, exposing a big structural problem, because in the case of a PSFP player:

  • The issuer (the company raising the funds) issues bonds;
  • The platform selects the projects (it is the judge);
  • The platform markets the bonds (it is a party);
  • The platform becomes the bondholders’ representative (it is supposed to defend the investors).

So to act against the issuer for failure to provide pre-contractual information, or even against the platform that selected the project and prepared the documents shown to investors, you have to go through... the platform itself.

This case law tends to give the platforms broad protection:

  • Through the monopoly on collective action (CAPSSA/HEM case law)
  • And through the total absence of any duty to inform or advise placed on the representative (Paris Court of Appeal, 2023)

This legal combination creates a genuine “lock”, making the representative almost untouchable in the event of an initial breach, even if the Ayomi case is a reminder that the most serious breaches can be punished.

It’s no accident, in fact, that in the classic bond system the bondholders’ representative is usually an independent body: a specialist law firm or an external management company. Its sole role is to protect the bondholders’ interests. As a lawyer specialising in financial law recently explained to me.

Independence, he told me, is the very foundation of the bond system, and without it the whole chain of trust collapses.

Yet it is precisely this independence that was sacrificed on the altar of crowdfunding. In the name of simplification, and probably of cost savings, we created a system where the conflict of interest is not the exception, but the rule.

For the average investor, the situation is hopeless:

  • Individual action over a general failure to inform? Impossible, according to the case law.
  • Collective action through the representative? Blocked by the blatant conflict of interest.

Granted, individual actions remain possible in theory in the case of a fault specific to one investor (such as faulty personalised advice). But in the vast majority of cases concerning the general information about the project, which makes up most of the risk in crowdfunding, the case law blocks individual action entirely.

And if the problem is only visible now, it’s because when everything’s fine… well, everything’s fine.