💥 Zero Bullshit

MaPrimeRénov: the real reason it was suspended.

And why the scheme should be killed off.

After several years of budget cuts, MaPrimeRénov’, France’s flagship grant for making homes more energy efficient, has been abruptly suspended, officially from July to December. A surprising decision, because it came as unexpectedly as a hair on the head of Éric Lombard, France’s economy minister, and at the same time as a scathing report from the Cour des comptes, France’s national audit court, on the DPE, the energy rating a home needs before it can be sold or let.

The building trade has been whingeing ever since (roughly as often as the CGT, France’s most militant trade union, calls a strike) and Macron made a point of saying the scheme would be kept. Still, I think it is high time we realised just how much of a shambles the funding of energy renovation is, and more broadly of property, and more broadly still of public finances. Messier than a protest camp after a week of rain.

Every year when I fill in my tax return, I marvel at the number of boxes and special cases, piling complexity on complexity… often for very little. Honestly, can anyone explain why letting out a house is taxed as property income, but switches to the BIC regime, the tax on business profits (micro-BIC, simplified BIC, Bic biro or whatever), as soon as you put a chest of drawers and a bed in it?

And what about the 177 tax breaks that let you write off anything and everything, from the tax credit for theatre productions of dramatic works or circuses to the VAT exemption for sea transport of people and goods in Guadeloupe, Martinique and La Réunion? Not to mention the taxes that probably cost more to collect than they bring in, like the famous annual tax on personal watercraft, the new name of the annual francisation and navigation duty once it was merged with the annual passport duty (yep, really). Basically, the yacht tax. It was supposed to bring in €10M a year, and collected barely €300K in 20191. It was €60K in 2024.

The problem is that France has become an empire of taxation (and tax breaks), with measures that cost a fortune. Sometimes they are measured, like the countless reduced VAT rates, the FCPI (innovation funds that come with a tax break) or the CIR, the research tax credit, which we know without a shadow of a doubt, after years, are useless. Sometimes they are simply forgotten in an expensive administrative drawer.

But what about MaPrimeRénov’, which the left has wept over every year for 5 years whenever its budget was cut… even though it was never fully spent? And which nobody seems willing to defend any more, now that the scheme has been abruptly suspended.

Well, guess what: life is beautifully arranged, because that is today’s topic!

  • Information on the funds of Novaxia, a French real estate fund manager;
  • A CTO or developer who knows COBOL inside out;
  • Delivery riders, entrepreneurs or lawyers connected to quick commerce or fast food delivery;
  • A lawyer or victims in the Aristophil, Bio’C’Bon and Marne&Finance cases.