💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Really Good Earnings

Because as so often, the original idea is a good one: award an RGE label54 to tradespeople, to make sure they follow a set of specifications, and so assume the work is done properly. Except that this assumption overlooks two problems.

  • France is badly short of building tradespeople. So cutting the number of professionals allowed to do what is a nationwide task inevitably drives prices up through scarcity.
  • Any financial aid that is not targeted only pushes prices up. Like reduced VAT for certain sectors, the aid ends up being captured by the professionals rather than benefiting consumers.

That second point has already been highlighted by a host of reports, including from the Cour des comptes (reduced VAT in property and restaurants in particular) and the Courbon/Labaronne parliamentary report55 (housing benefit, VAT and so on), and demonstrated many times abroad. But we told ourselves that, this time, it would be different (it wasn’t).

In rural areas, the situation quickly began to look like a tradespeople desert. The distribution of RGE firms reveals a gaping territorial divide: entire départements are left with a handful of certified tradespeople, creating endless waiting times and prices that soar for lack of competition.

As early as 2016, UFC-Que Choisir, a French consumer association, calculated extra costs of up to 185%56. But the warning was ignored and, unsurprisingly, for 10 years every study has shown the same thing: roughly speaking, the difference between jobs before RGE or without it… is the amount of MaPrimeRénov’. So the state is simply funding margin. In the building trade, I am told that being RGE is actually expensive, and that the extra cost mainly goes to pay for… the regulations imposed by the state. Indeed, for several years now the CAPEB57 has been warning about the fall in the number of RGE firms58.

Number of RGE-certified firms over time59
Note: the CAPEB warning dates from 2023 and the clear fall was recorded over 2023-2024

Either way, it clearly does nothing for renovation, as the Cour des comptes confirms.