💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 07

MaPrimeNightmare

But the malfunctions also hit tradespeople, who have suffered systemic delays almost since the scheme was launched, to the point of putting many businesses in difficulty. According to Joyce Pitcher, a lawyer, more than 2,500 cases are currently in litigation51. The cause: delays of up to 12 months after the works in some areas… and sometimes even longer. All for files worth €10K-€15K that have already been processed over 2 to 3 years.

Case in point: at the end of 2023, only 64% of the 2.3M applications filed between 2020 and 2023 had been paid out…

Not to mention what some call the ‘non-consent’ trap. At a time when lawmakers have just banned cold calling because citizens were harassed for years, the ANAH calls from a withheld number months after the works to check. If there is no answer after 1 or 2 attempts, the file is stamped as non-consent and payment is refused. This leads the ANAH to claw back grants after the fact in 70% of cases. And some intermediaries handling the files go as far as turning against the households… who have no idea what has just happened to them.

The practice led some companies, such as Drapo, to stop handling MaPrimeRénov' files altogether after running into complications on a third of their files52.

Which leads many French people never to take the plunge (or cross the threshold) into renovation. Especially since there is no shortage of other reasons.

Beyond the administrative nightmare and the question of financial return (and funding), renovations are, above all, building works. And everyone knows the syndrome of the job that spirals out of control. Here again, there are countless accounts of people living with tarpaulins for windows, or without hot water because the boiler still has not been fitted after months. Missed deadlines, unexpected extra costs, hefty upfront payments… For many, energy renovation is a big risk, especially when the benefits are not always really felt.

The phenomenon is made worse by a series of scandals that left their mark. The ‘€1 insulation’ offers, a tempting promise that turned into a nightmare for thousands of households, left deep scars. Both among the victims and among those harassed daily on the phone about insulation, heating and other remote smooth-talkers. Several studies53 confirm that this mistrust grew even stronger after some grants were abruptly scrapped, giving the impression of an unstable and unreliable system.

To top it all, the state has had fun adding instability on top of a lack of trust. While it is true that the MaPrimeRénov’ name now enjoys real recognition, you really have to wonder what the point is of changing the name and the schemes every 5 years, and of multiplying initiatives under different names, rather than building on a single, simple system.

Especially since it is not just the name. The constant changes to grant schemes and the sudden rule changes feed a sense of legal and financial insecurity:

  • Regular changes to rates and eligibility conditions;
  • Sudden scrapping of some grants without notice;
  • The impression of a short-term energy policy, with no coherent vision.

This perceived instability reinforces the wait-and-see attitude of many owners, who prefer to postpone their renovation plans in the hope of better conditions, or for fear of committing to a scheme that could change along the way.

And as so often, all this came with some truly botched decisions.