As we saw earlier, because the DPE carries regulatory weight, ratings ended up pushing prices down… but also up. The first signs date from 2021, but it is now glaring, and homes rated A or B now command premiums of +4% to +20%.
Because for years, many politicians (who have partly convinced the French) have pitted the end of the world against making it to the end of the month, or talk about punitive ecology, when they do not go as far as calling people green Khmer Rouge. Quite apart from the fact that we will probably end up seeing a real ecological dictatorship in the years to come (vaguely foretold, like quite a few other things, by Plamondon in Starmania, the French rock opera, 40 years ago), it has become nonsense. Because in reality, sure, patching a leaking roof saves you paying for a new one, but in the end you will have to replace the frame, not just the tiles. So it is a bad financial calculation. Except that you need the money now.
But several studies tend to show that the poorest live in the least energy-efficient homes, and so end up paying higher bills. It is staggering, by the way, that rent caps, always championed by left-wing politicians, have never taken this into account. Because between an F home and an A home, the impact on the tenant’s energy spending is clearly not the same.
As for owners… that is a whole other story. Because the inequalities are mainly territorial. And hard to overcome with any genuinely smart policy. So let’s say insurmountable.
It is not very hard to understand. A renovation costs roughly the same everywhere. Between €500 and €1,000 per m², depending on the size of the home and the scale of the works. In Saint-Menges, in the Ardennes (a lovely village, the Germans never fail to drop in), property sells for around €800 per m². So even with a cheap renovation, the market will never be able to absorb such an increase.
In a mid-sized town like Épinal, a full energy renovation costs around €40K for an 80 m² house. Compared with the total value of the property (€144K), that investment represents nearly 28% of its value.
Overall, a renovation costs between €20K and €60K22. But in Paris, for an average flat of the same size, the cost of renovation is much the same. Yet set against a property worth €880K, it represents only 4.5% of its value. The gap is staggering, and that amount could easily be accepted by a buyer, or absorbed by the natural rise in prices.
In that same city, the discount on an energy sieve is -5%. It is -21% in the Grand Est.
Energy savings in 2020 relative to the floor area of main residences, in MWh/year per 100 m²23
This asymmetry is directly reflected in the return on investment. According to the ONRE, the average payback period for a full renovation is 15 to 20 years in rural areas and mid-sized towns, against 7 to 10 years in the big cities, where energy savings come on top of a bigger rise in property value. Whereas the average time a property is held is between 10 and 15 years24.
And if you dig a little deeper, 70% of the gains are concentrated in houses, while it is flats that are most affected… A problem one could happily pin on the managing agents of shared buildings… forgetting that more often than not it is the co-owners who do not want to pay, especially when they are only landlords, and that sometimes… the works are simply not possible, or extremely expensive.
As for the famous MaPrimeRénov’, it leaves households with an average out-of-pocket share of 42%25, but it is 64% for modest-income households, and 47% for very low-income ones26.
Yet on average, the less well-off live in the cheapest areas, so their renovations will never pay off when they sell, since MaPrimeRénov’ takes no account whatsoever of location.
And yet the scheme is in less demand in the big cities. The France Relance 2024 report points to a significant drop in applications for MaPrimeRénov' in large urban areas such as Paris or Lyon, despite their considerable population. Conversely, rural and peri-urban areas, where the property return on investment is structurally lower, account for a growing share of renovations, according to ONRE data for 2023.
Energy savings by type of municipality, in 2020, in %27
The irony is bitter: where renovation would make the most economic sense (in the big cities), it is done least. And where it weighs most heavily on household budgets (rural areas and mid-sized towns), it becomes almost unavoidable to keep the property’s value.
Paradoxically, household emissions fell by 3.6% in 202328… but it is a misleading figure, a bit like vehicle emissions falling during Covid. It is mainly down to milder winter weather, more than to modest improvements in energy efficiency. Global warming is almost a stroke of luck against heating use…
But add to that the rising running costs of homes (energy, property taxes and so on) and persistent difficulties in sourcing materials (whose costs are rising too), and you end up with owners who have little incentive to do the works since, financially:
That, in fact, is where MaPrimeRénov’ should have started.