The current attempts to rescue MaPrimeRénov' follow a purely political logic, disconnected from how well it actually works. The FFB62 openly deplores any questioning of a scheme that is a substantial source of funding for its members.
Some politicians also defend the status quo, such as Paul Midy, an MP straight out of the KPI-obsessed start-up nation, who backs every scheme funding his former colleagues’ start-ups, regardless of the many reports showing they do not work.
Conversely, the alternatives have barely been tested. While it is true that the CEE provide massive funding, that is mainly due to a European regulation on carbon taxation, whose limits, sometimes bordering on greenwashing, are well known. But with a sometimes virtuous effect. Third-party financing is also being tested, with local public-private companies (or private firms) topping up the files. The seven trials are still being evaluated.
Abroad, examples are rare, but they have had real results. In Germany, where 5.6M homes have been fully renovated since 2006, with a simple and clear grant, at a cost of around €48K per home. Or in the Netherlands with Energiesprong, whose cost fell from €145K to €70K per home, but with only 10K homes under contract.
In reality, the underlying problem is complex. It means catching up, in 20 years, on nearly 2 centuries of massive, clumsy and uncontrolled urban development, when France has had no long-term urban policy since the start of the century, no stable housing policy, and MPs would rather tear each other apart over ZFEs, low-emission zones, or the ZAN, the target of zero net land take.
The current situation presents a fundamental paradox, by the way: while the climate emergency has never been more pressing and renovation technologies have never been more effective, the French system meant to ease this transition has become, through its complexity and malfunctions, one of the main obstacles to that very transition.
And yet we can see the reality. Some towns can no longer get insurance. Natural disasters are happening more and more often. Costing more and more. Subsidence caused by clay soils shrinking and swelling will cost several billion over a few years. And just as we were debating whether or not to cut cars in our city centres, a Swiss glacier wiped an entire village off the map. Not on the other side of the world, in countries nobody cares about and everyone prefers to ignore. A few kilometres from the French-Swiss border.
Behind the figures and the official reports (which we care about roughly as much as the climate consequences on the other side of the world) are millions of French people who end up giving up, beaten by a system meant to help them but which, paradoxically, has itself become the main obstacle to renovation. This is all the more worrying as the national energy renovation targets look increasingly out of reach under current conditions.
A thorough overhaul of the system now seems essential. It should be built around a few fundamental principles:
Without these structural changes, there is a real risk that France will keep falling behind in the necessary energy transition of its housing stock, with major consequences both environmental and social.
Here as elsewhere, the cost of inaction will be considerable. Because some of these homes have a direct effect on emissions, while others are in areas that will eventually become uninhabitable. And that is without counting the cost to health and public health.
Conversely, the transition in buildings, as in every sector, is a major driver of local jobs, which, what is more, are not at all threatened by technological change or geopolitical conflicts.
But we know the reality.
And so nothing will change.
At Zero Bullshit, we often talk about the industry’s problems. But we also need to offer solutions. That is why we now work with a partner specialising in support for, and funding of, complex financial, wealth or family disputes.
This firm brings together a pool of experts, backed by a solid group with more than €100M in capital.
In practice: if you are facing a long and costly financial dispute, we can look at the case. And the work will only be paid for if it succeeds.