Who still remembers the jubilation when the Paris Agreement was signed? The famous COP21, which ended nearly 10 years ago, on 12 December 2015. 196 parties agreed to curb global warming, and in particular their emissions, with 2050 in their sights. The year many companies, countries and industries chose as their target for el famoso net zero.
France is no exception.
Nor are its homes.
And France has 37.2M of them. A fine collection of walls, roofs and windows, many of which hold heat about as well as a sieve holds water. Inside, French people who discover every winter that the 21st century has not quite reached their radiator yet. Especially when energy prices soar. Because although everyone mocked Macron when he said it was the end of abundance, he was right. Massive use of fossil fuels, including for heating, will never be as cheap as it used to be. Very soon, nobody will be able to emit without paying for their own pollution. Because the direct emissions of French households in 2023 came to 101 Mt CO₂ eq2. And while greenhouse gas emissions have fallen by 31% since 1990, that is mainly thanks to lower industrial emissions, themselves the result of massive offshoring on one side and changes in production methods on the other. On the household side, nothing much has ever been done.
The housing figures are dizzying. Depending on who is counting and how (a national sport if ever there was one), France has between 4.2M and 5.8M passoires thermiques, ‘energy sieves’, the worst-rated homes. The ONRE3 says 5.5M, of which 4.2M are main residences. The Cour des comptes leans towards 5.8M, of which 5.3M are privately owned4. France Relance, the post-Covid recovery plan, put it at 5.2M in 20225. In short, nobody agrees, but everybody agrees it is far too many.
Residential buildings alone produce 11% of France’s greenhouse gases. Add commercial and public buildings and between 20% and 25%6 of national emissions go up in smoke. Literally. According to the CITEPA, which keeps France’s emissions inventory, buildings spew out 69.9M t CO₂ eq7 out of a total of 418.2M, or 18%8. Over at INSEE, the national statistics office, which likes to count differently, households are said to emit 101M t CO₂ eq directly, from their heating and their cars alone. Either way, it is the most energy-hungry sector in the country. And overall, 95% of a French person’s carbon footprint comes down to their 3 Cs9: their chow, their car, their crib. Which, incidentally, leaves little room for the fintech bullshit about the emissions of your bank account, as Bon Pote, a French climate blog, brilliantly demonstrated (here then here then here again and then here once more, all in French).
Greenhouse gas emissions from residential buildings over time (in MtCO2eq)10
That said, the geography of cold homes draws a peculiar map of France. The sieves are concentrated along a diagonal running from the central Pyrenees to the north-east, the famous diagonale du vide, the ‘empty diagonal’ of rural France, where old buildings sit alongside modest incomes. The big cities fare better: in Paris, an energy sieve loses only 5% of its value. In the Grand Est region, in the north-east, 21% vanishes. Territorial injustice in all its glory. Probably for a purely economic reason, which we will get to shortly. But also because homes are overwhelmingly heated with fossil fuels (gas in particular, which was widely recommended for years, especially once it had been labelled natural), and how much is used also depends on the climate where the home is.
Share of energy sieves by département in 202111
Départements in dark green have a share of energy sieves above 25%
Renovation works compared with energy sieves in the first half of 202312
The sieve reduction index is above 1.1 (dark green) when the département’s share of renovations is higher than its share of energy sieves
Behind these percentages, 12M French people live in fuel poverty13: 14% of the population said they suffered from the cold at home last winter. Not in 1954, when a now-disgraced priest made his famous appeal for people freezing in the streets. Last winter, some seventy years later. These households spend a disproportionate share of their income trying to heat the unheatable, when they do not simply give up.
Things are improving, apparently. At least if you listen to the politicians. Between 2022 and 2024, the share of energy sieves fell from 19.5% to 15.6%. And every year, Macron congratulated himself (since nobody else would do it for him) on the number of renovations.
Breakdown of main residences by DPE energy rating (in %), at 1 January 2023
At 1 January 2023, the share of main residences that are energy sieves stood at 15.7%14
Marginal, is the Cour des comptes’ sober verdict. At this rate, France will hit its climate targets at about the same time French unicorns turn a profit.
Because the targets, for their part, are ambitious. France has committed to renovating between 400K and 500K homes a year, depending on the source. The SNBC15 demands 370K high-performance renovations a year straight away, then 700K after 2030. The Cour des comptes, ever the optimist, reckons we should rather aim for a million high-performance renovations a year. Bearing in mind that in reality 1.26 million homes a year would need renovating to have any hope of reaching net zero in 2050.
Let’s do a quick sum. It is 2025, and there are 25 years left to renovate 5.5M homes.
On paper, the state is not stingy. €7bn of public spending in 2021, plus €6.3bn from the recovery plan. Sums that would make any ministry’s budget blush. And yet the ANAH, the state housing agency that runs the scheme, congratulated itself on supporting 650K renovations in 2022, then fewer than 595K in 2023. Nowhere near enough. That makes 220K a year. Except that… the 5.5M are only the F and G ratings. And to reach net zero, every home would need to reach C, or D at the very least. Not only is that very hard for some homes, especially in shared buildings, it would mean quadrupling the current pace.
Especially since the problem is not only about energy and money. It is also about health. Badly insulated, damp homes that cannot be heated properly bring their share of illnesses. Respiratory diseases, joint problems, winter depression. The cold kills, slowly but surely.
So much for the backdrop.
Millions of energy sieves, millions of people in fuel poverty, sky-high targets and a reality that struggles to take off. In this mess, France found THE solution: MaPrimeRénov'. The miracle scheme that was supposed to change everything.