MaPrimeRénov' spends public money, which means it must be useful and have a measurable impact. Yet the available data show that this scheme mostly funds work… with little impact on energy use.
To put it simply, the initial aim was to bring every home up to at least C. Then, in the end, D. So these renovations absolutely have to change all that. But the vast majority of the time, it is more a case of people who want or need to replace a boiler or some windows, and check whether there is a grant lying around to cut the bill.
In 2024, only 350K renovations were carried out, against a target of 700K34. Which is already not great.
But above all: fewer than 10% of these renovations involve major works, the only ones of real value for energy.
Worse: fewer than 6% of funded renovations result in a jump of at least 2 DPE classes. And more generally, 86% of applications in 2021 involved only a single measure, mainly replacing the heating system (72%) or insulation (26%)35.
Basically, we are handing out cash for things that do not meet the objective at all. We are (literally) throwing money out of the window.
Recent figures confirm the trend. In 2023, whole-house renovations accounted for only 1.7%36. In Q1 2025, the ANAH counted 249,427 single-measure applications against only 91,374 whole-house renovations. Which, according to several calculations, broadly means that only 3% of floor area has undergone a whole-house renovation, even though that represents 10% of energy savings in 202037.
Especially since MaPrimeRénov’ in fact accounts for only 4% of the total energy savings generated by the grants, far behind the CEE, energy savings certificates, which account for 81% of the gains. And also for a large share of the funding, since on average the out-of-pocket share after MaPrimeRénov’ is 70%, falling to 58%38 with the CEE39.
As for the energy gain, it is estimated at just 3.5 TWh/year, or 0.8% of French residential consumption, with an average saving per home of 5.7 MWh/year.40 Heat pumps alone account for a quarter of the measures but two thirds of the energy savings thanks to their high efficiency (13.9 MWh/year per home on average)41, but they are also the most expensive measure (€21K on average), while wood stoves and pellet boilers, though effective, cost less but leave a hefty out-of-pocket bill. Reason enough for a fair few tradesmen’s lobbies to defend the scheme whatever it takes.
Energy savings by type of measure funded under the CEE, the CITE and MaPrimeRénov’, in TWh/year42
* Ventilation, connection to heating networks
This is partly explained by the considerable gap between the costs of the different types of renovation. A whole-house renovation costs €40K on average, and reaching BBC level43 takes €60K-€70K44. By comparison, standard MaPrimeRénov' funds only €11.3K on average45, and single-measure renovations only get grants of €2,000 to €5,000 depending on income.
In climate terms, the impact is just as inadequate. The CO₂ reduction is estimated at 1.8 Mt CO₂ eq/year, below the SNBC target of 2.5 Mt CO₂ eq/year. Actual savings are thought to be between 1.3 and 1.8 Mt CO₂ eq/year, or only 4% of residential sector emissions46. If you take the 2023 figures, for example, France’s carbon footprint fell by 4.1%… but much of that came from lower imports rather than effective action at home, which points to a disconnect between the measures taken (such as partial renovations) and the real impact on domestic emissions47.
Especially since several studies show a decoupling between household energy consumption and the associated emissions, which suggests that in reality, the theoretical gains do not translate directly into an effective and lasting cut in emissions48. Possibly because the gain was only theoretical, or because, and this behaviour has been observed elsewhere, when the bill goes down, people pay a little less attention.
An inadequacy compounded by the pace of renovation we saw above… To reach net zero in 2050, and taking these real-world parameters into account, France would need to renovate 1.26M homes a year. It was 650K in 2022 and 595K in 2023.
Home energy renovation targets set by the state, over time49
In total, 2.4M homes were renovated from 2020 to September 2024, of which only 330,000 were whole-house renovations. A far cry from the target of a million high-performance renovations a year.
An €8bn load of bullshit.
MaPrimeRénov’ renovation figures, 2020 to H1 2025 (cumulative)