💥 Zero Bullshit

SCIs inside SCPIs: the great opacity (episode 2 / 2)

How do SCIs make some SCPIs completely opaque? 🕳️

A fortnight ago I told you about SCIs, French property-holding companies, used as real-estate investment units inside French life-insurance policies (in French), and explained what a fine mess they make of transparency.

Back then I briefly touched on SCPIs, France’s unlisted real-estate investment funds, and that was supposed to be the next episode, until Luko, the French home-insurance start-up, came along and changed my plans (in French). That said, all is well: the subject hasn’t changed. 😎

The subject strikes me as particularly interesting at a time when some people are trying to explain that “oh come ooooon, it’s just a few SCPIs and it’s temporaaaaary”, when we are talking about 40% of the market’s capitalisation that has just corrected.

And because, contrary to what Jean-Marc Coly, chairman of ASPIM (the property-funds lobby), has said, managers did not adjust their prices out of courage, but because the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, forced them to last May.

Even though my SCI story has no direct link to that, we’ll see that it’s still not entirely insignificant.

Illustration for the newsletter “SCIs inside SCPIs: the great opacity (episode 2 / 2)”