To my mind, this raises two issues.
1️⃣ There is, of course, transparency.
None of these SCIs has ever filed its accounts and we know nothing about what goes on inside. Unlike directly held assets, the income, the split of charges, the commissions, etc. are never clearly stated. So how can you tell whether the management is really any good? Sometimes the manager is the same management company, sometimes it’s another one (on HOLD, for example), and other times it’s an outside manager (that’s the case for the SCI that runs the WeWork Marais in Paris).
2️⃣ But above all, if there is a certain correlation between falling unit prices and the managers who make heavy use of SCIs, there’s a reason. Not because it implies bad management. But because a large share of these SCIs were used to blow the money raised on very big assets (even if some did the same without SCIs).
The 14 largest of the 25 vehicles that cut their unit price had a combined capitalisation of €29bn in 2022, or 34% of the market.
Between 2018 and 2022, although these vehicles are 28 years old on average, they raised:
It reaches 61% at Europimmo, 56% at Accimo, 49% at PF Grand Paris.
Of course this figure is also high in the neo-SCPIs, at Pierval Santé or at Corum… but with much younger vehicles.
These SCIs made it possible to buy huge assets, sometimes split between several in-house vehicles, and so to spend massive inflows even when it was not in the partners’ interest.