💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

NotAllScpi

While some keep talking about “the SCPI market” or “should you sell your units or not”, it seems obvious that this is a two-speed market.

  • Between those who gorge themselves on entry fees, and those trying another model: why cap your inflows when they are what pays at the door?;
  • Between those who blow the money raised fighting over the same assets, and those who look further ahead;
  • Between those who run their vehicle the old-fashioned way, and those who are giving the partners transparency again.

Because I think it’s worth recalling what an SCPI is.

When La Française puts “LF” in front of all its SCPIs stuffed with LF-branded SCIs, or Primonial slaps a Primo-whatsit on all its vehicles to remind everyone who’s boss, they forget that they are merely service providers to the partners.

An SCPI belongs to its partners.

The management company is paid… to manage.

It is not ITS vehicle that it opens to subscription like an ordinary fund.

This money belongs to them. The buildings belong to them. And that, in fact, is what sets an SCPI apart from most other investment products.

It is when the market turns that you can tell the good managers from the bad. Not when everything was fine and the money was pouring in.

I have read several times that it’s only a few SCPIs out of more than 200.

That’s wrong.

  • There are 111 diversified SCPIs, the rest are tax-break schemes (whose performance is even worse)
  • 25 falling SCPIs out of 111 is 23%…
  • … but above all they account for 40% of the capitalisation

We are talking about €4.2bn of savings that have just gone up in smoke.

And even though the SCPI is an income product rather than a growth product, the performance of these vehicles is still lousy. Over 5 years it’s:

  • -5.07% of yield lost on average
  • -11.4% lost on the unit price on average

On average, if you had put €10,000 into these SCPIs, you would have €11,163 today, an average IRR of 2.33%.

Better still: 86% of the losses are concentrated at 5 managers:

  • Amundi
  • BNP
  • Primonial
  • Perial
  • AEW

Enough to call their management strategies into question, and to ask why so many distributors kept on selling these vehicles.

The signs had been there for a long time.