💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 07

A common practice

And it is anything but anecdotal.

Not only because it concerns a large share of some SCPIs, but above all because it sometimes indirectly finances the same management company.

For example, in 2019, Primopierre advanced €39M through a partner’s current account to the OPCI Preim Lumière… also managed by Primonial. Granted, the advance pays interest. But less than 1.8% at the time. That obviously raises a conflict-of-interest problem.

The same year, the SCPI received:

  • €100M in rent and €110M in dividends from SCIs.
  • It was €94M / €98M in 2018
  • It is €103M / €125M in 2022

In 2022, Primopierre still has considerable sums (€337M) in partners’ current accounts in vehicles managed by Primonial, including:

  • €36M in the SCI Preim Bloom
  • €163M in the SCI Nexxt Gambetta
  • €53 in the SCI Hublot Défense
  • €42M in the OPCI Preim Lumière, etc.

The weight of these SCI investments is huge. Of Primopierre’s €3.277bn of property, €1.1bn sits in opaque SCIs (and 2 OPCIs) whose management we know nothing about.

Not every management company does this.

Among recent SCPIs, it is even completely absent. Kyaneos states clearly, in fact, that it makes no use of indirect investments. Same at Iroko, Log In etc.

Epsilon 360, for its part, made a small acquisition through an SCI it owns 99.9% of, and Remake Live has an SCI it owns 100% of, whose accounts it sets out in detail.

In most cases, when an SCPI owns an SCI, it is linked to a bundled purchase, like the 4 assets of the SCI Hopla held by Épargne Pierre (Atland).

These are clearly strategic choices. SCIs are everywhere at some managers, while they are marginal at others (Perial, Sofidy, etc.). There are 2 main reasons:

  • The bigger the SCPI, the bigger the assets it invests in…
  • And the bigger the management company, the more it pools its investments across its own vehicles

For example, in Épargne Foncière, the largest vehicle on the market, 44% of the assets are in SCIs, the vast majority of whose names begin with “LF”.

When LF Equinox was set up in 2019 to buy 129 Felix Faure in Lyon, the group’s 4 big SCPIs were each brought in for 25%, with, for each of them… the same corporate officer signing the articles of association

.

Sometimes only two SCPIs are involved (e.g. LF Grand Paris Patrimoine and Épargne foncière in the case of LF Bois Colombes).

For some, notably the biggest, this choice is almost systematic

  • All in at Amundi
    Edissimo: 64% of capitalisation in SCIs
    Genepierre: 66%
    Rivoli Avenir Patrimoine: 63%
  • Off the charts at Primonial
    Patrimmo Commerce: 28%
    Patrimmo Impact: 7.5%
    Primofamily: 26%
    Primopierre: 33%
    Ufifrance: 32%
    Primovie: 29%
  • Less so at BNP
    Accimo: 12%
    France Investipierre: 6%
    Accès Valeur Pierre: 4%
    Opus Real, Pierre Selection, Soporente: 0%

And it is also the norm in most of the SCPIs run by AEW.