💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Coeur Défense: the yield’s heart attack

So, even if we know nothing about the investment, is this sublime €1.8bn tower a great investment? 😅

Well, if I’m pretending to ask, you know the answer.

For Edissimo, the value estimated by the valuers keeps on falling:

  • 2018: €85.9M
  • 2019: €84.2M
  • 2020: €73.4M
  • 2021: €73M
  • 2022: €63M

That’s a 27% loss in 5 years. 🤡

A figure strangely out of line with Primopierre, which said it had paid €80.5M for a book value of €71.9M in 2017, then estimated at €74M.

Perhaps because CBRE (Edissimo’s valuer) and BNP REREVF (Primopierre’s) don’t use the same frameworks. But the gap is puzzling.

Be that as it may, in 2022, BNP REVF values it at €46.2M.
That’s a 35% loss.
For the same SCI holding the same building.

On dividends, same story. At Edissimo, they go from €4.5M in 2018 to €3.4M in 2021. Surprise: in 2022… the SCI vanishes altogether from the list of financial income. Even though Edissimo still has €10M in a partner’s current account in the SCI.

Primopierre, for its part, reports €1.3M in dividends in 2022, against €3.2M in 2018.

But how do you explain such a drop in valuation and yield?

Well.

No idea.

Because while the SCPI is clear about its fees, its pay, its expenses, etc. for the properties it holds directly, the same doesn’t go for the SCIs. Precisely because from them it receives dividends, not rents.