Normally, the figures in the annual reports let you understand the investments made by SCPIs. Except that… Not always, as this case I’ve been dying to tell you about shows.
The story begins in 2001. After years of works, Unibail, the French property group, delivers 350,000m² of offices in a building designed by the architect Jean-Paul Viguier. Built on the site of the former Esso building, demolished in 1993, the very narrow twin towers (24m wide) rise to 161m and are joined in the middle. Three 8-storey buildings complete the complex, which is then, along with the enormous Romanian parliament in Bucharest, the largest property complex in Europe.
In 2004, Goldman Sachs buys the whole thing from Unibail for €1.3bn, before selling it on to Lehman in 2007 for €2.1bn. Lehman sets up for the occasion the SCI Heart of La Défense (HOLD), named after Paris’s main business district and owned by a Luxembourg holding company (for the mild climate, I imagine). The SCI’s registered office is next door to Télé Z, a French TV-listings magazine (yes, the one whose dog mascot knows what’s on tonight).
Extract from the transaction, which gives an idea of the property
When Lehman collapses in 2008, HOLD is one of the firm’s biggest assets and the SCI is placed in safeguard proceedings, a French court-protected restructuring. Its debt is securitised, then bought by a whole bunch of players, and a legal mess follows until 2014, when Lone Star Capital puts €1.3bn on the table thanks to 2 credit lines from Merrill Lynch.
The occupancy rate is then 77%, and the building will never be profitable. In 2015, Lone Star collects €72M in rent (a 5.5% yield), and €61M in 2016 (4.7%). At the time, the main tenants are HSBC (25%), Allianz (6%) and RTE-EDF (8%)2.
In 2017, it is the asset managers Primonial and Amundi and the insurer Crédit Agricole Assurances who stump up €1.8bn to buy the sublime corridors with their blue carpets, and the splendid partition walls, modern in the 1950s sense of the word.
And this is where the story really begins (yeah, until now I was just kidding):
Then puts another 20% into OPCIMMO, an OPCI, another kind of French property fund (which itself holds units in its SCPIs).
That leaves 55%, which must be languishing in funds, property companies and other unit-linked products we know nothing about.
Sharp-eyed sleuths will have noticed that we have here the winning four-horse accumulator of 2023, in exact order, with the full-house losers’ bingo bonus.
Well done, it’s a bouncing baby.
Congratulations to the managers.
And I doubt anyone can claim HOLD had nothing to do with it.
Especially as it closed its financial year with €84M in losses.
At the time of the purchase, Edissimo had a capitalisation of €2.626bn. Its €370M in fresh money from investors (plus a few asset sales) let it spend €1.12bn, spread across… 16 buildings. That’s €70M per investment on average.
Two were held directly by the SCPI, all the others through SCIs.