💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

Why is that a problem?

Well, because it’s hard to read.

In Edissimo’s 2017 accounts, we do find 10.67% of the SCI Hold, bought for €192,060,000: which does give an SCI valued at €1.8bn.

On the RAP (Rivoli Avenir Patrimoine) side, the 8.76% is valued at €157,680,000, which is consistent.

At Génépierre, the 2017 accounts are no longer available. We learn in 2018 that its 5.02% was bought for €45,683,337, an odd valuation of €910M.

Same oddity at Primopierre, where the 8.5% has a purchase price of €80,535,137, valuing the SCI at €942M.

Where’s the mistake? In reality, it may be less a mistake than a complicated accounting reality.

👉 Let’s stick with Edissimo.

  • In the acquisitions, the stake in HOLD shows a purchase price of €192M for the 10.67%
  • In the valuation of investments, the book value is €97M
  • In the financial fixed assets, there is a building at €233M, -€96M and -€51M of debt, for a purchase price of… €86.2M and an estimated value of €90M

Why such complicated figures? Because some relate to the company (the SCI) while others relate to its underlying asset (the building). And even though the building has a value, the SCI itself booked an accounting loss of €125M.

So how much did the SCPI pay to buy HOLD and its Coeur Défense building?

Well… Hard to say. Because there appear to have been loans both inside the SCI and to finance the purchase of the SCI. It is never clearly explained.