Now, I don’t like speaking ill of people, but wealth management advisers who don’t give independent advice are useless. There, I said it. Better still: they shouldn’t exist any more. And according to the professional bodies, we’re talking about 95% of the profession.
The term “independent” has been regulated by the AMF since 2018 and MiFID II, the EU’s investment services rules.
The rule is simple:
As the saying goes: if it’s free, you’re the product.
So the case of non-independent CIFs strikes me as serious.
It’s no accident that they’re the ones pushing most of the SCPIs, Pinel (a French tax-break scheme for buy-to-let new-builds) and other investments that pay well (for them): these are turnkey products.
How many of them help those investors with buy-to-let in an existing, not new-build, property, for example?
And the case of SCPIs is actually rather amusing.
All summer I watched CGPs scrambling to draw up Good SCPI vs. Bad SCPI tables, using ratios that make no sense, to work out which would fall and which would rise. Quite apart from getting a good chunk of them wrong, they forget one major thing: an SCPI is a property portfolio.
And frankly: all you had to do was read the annual reports of most of the SCPIs that have just marked down to know it would end badly.
Take Primopierre. Its yield has kept on collapsing:
And the third quarter of 2021 was propped up by a payout 25% funded by assets that were sold.
A yield far below office SCPIs, with a worrying financial occupancy rate that swung between 86% and 91% over the period.
And yet 2022 was a record year of retail fundraising for Primonial, Primopierre’s manager, at €2.7bn.
How much of that came through advisers?
Impossible to say. The boss of a big asset manager tells me 5% at his firm and 10 to 20% elsewhere. An executive at a bank-owned asset manager rounds it to 10%.
Meanwhile, the CGPs and their representatives were up in arms against distributors who offered lower commissions, or when the commission on Pinel was capped at 10%. Even though it’s hard to see how extra commissions, and therefore less performance, could serve the investor.
And yet you can get an idea of what CGPs sell by looking at the Oscars they hand out every year, at award ceremonies run by trade rags (and tatty ones at that).