A few days ago, a friend sent me an article from Les Echos Investir, the investment title of the French business daily Les Echos.
“Immobilier : dois-je vendre mes parts de SCPI en cas de perte de valeur ?” [Property: should I sell my SCPI shares if they lose value?]
A woman explains that she is sitting on a paper loss of €60,000 on a BNP SCPI showing a lovely -17% (on top of the entry fees), and wonders whether she should sell. In a few sentences, and without ever writing those two little letters, the journalist answers: no.
But it was less the article that amused me than the one recommended underneath it:
A nice plug for Les Corbeilles 2023. So, for any newcomers passing through: despite the name (a corbeille is a wastepaper basket), Les Corbeilles aren’t the investments you should chuck in the bin: they’re the ones the editors think are super cool.
And guess who wins a stack of awards?
“Caisse d’Epargne et BNP Paribas multi-primés” [Caisse d’Epargne and BNP Paribas win multiple awards]
For 5 paragraphs, the journalist sucks up to a whole bunch of managers who are in the habit of buying ads in her paper. And here come the “top-notch asset managers”, and here’s the podium, in order, in a dozen categories nobody understands, etc. Finance’s very own school sports day: everyone gets a medal.
And if that’s not enough for you, you can click on the next one: “Grands Prix des Sicav : les lauréats 2023” [Sicav Grand Prix: the 2023 winners].
But obviously, nobody holds it against Investir in particular. Take Capimmo, which is showing -13% in 2023, one of the worst performances of any SCI. Well, it has two pretty labels:
Naturally, these 2 magazines have written an article about what’s going on at Capimmo. Just kidding, they couldn’t care less.
Because to proudly display an award logo on your website and your brochures, you have to pay between €4,000 and €5,000 a year. But hey, I’m sure there’s no link whatsoever between that and the everyone-gets-a-medal culture of finance.
But above all… Apart from a handful of people (probably like you, reading this right now), who cares about Gestion de Fortune or L’Agefi, a French financial news outlet?
This strange paradigm raises questions when this trade press runs ‘exclusives’ to grab a few clicks on a share price cut, when it never wrote a single article analysing the same fund back when it was objectively bad and badly positioned.
Is it a lack of competence, like that journalist at Le Figaro who asked, not so long ago, how an asset manager could pay notary fees (the hefty legal costs of buying property in France) if it didn’t charge entry fees?
Or the fear that the people paying €3,000-a-year subscriptions would bail out if anyone started looking a bit too closely at what they do day to day?